Better representative of the pfp#1 title. Floyd or Pac?

[Left Hook Tua]

I said nothing about turning down Oscar. He fought david diaz over nate campbell who is the man at 135. Age has nothing to do with being shot. Haven't Bernard shown us this countless times in last couple yrs. he should have fought Nate like Floyd fought Castillo before him. But he is taking on Hatton at jr WW. He gets credit for that but I don't hink he has fought better comp than Floyd. He fought a bunch of over the heel HOFers who wore themselves out by fighting each other 1st. And he is yet to convincingly beat JMM.

who was shot? erik and oscar?

funny......no one thought they were shot going into those fights.

of course after they get ktfo......they must be shot.

erik was shot during the 3rd fight. the 1st 2 he was past prime but still had it.

oscar might not even be shot. i think he was too worried about dieting instead of concentrating on training.

[Left Hook Tua]

when floyd fought gatti..hatton had already beat kostya....so my bad hatton was#1 but gatti was top 3 and that=pacmans win over diaz

that's fine.

gatti is equal to diaz.

diaz was just a tuneup for manny anyway.

[larryx]

that's fine.

gatti is equal to diaz.

diaz was just a tuneup for manny anyway.

i know and gatti was a tune up for floyd..pac and floyd are just leagues ahead of the rest..i cant down either..im a diehard floyd fan..but manny is a beast

[Left Hook Tua]

i know and gatti was a tune up for floyd..pac and floyd are just leagues ahead of the rest..i cant down either..im a diehard floyd fan..but manny is a beast

what kind of odds are you giving me when floyd-pac happens?

[larryx]

what kind of odds are you giving me when floyd-pac happens?

lol..im not betting on that fight..i never bet on floyd....

[williamhvx1]

A no brainer

[Ishy Aytan]

The lineal champ is not necsessarally the #1 guy in the division. This is certainly true for Gatti and Baldomir. Lineal is a line of succession, that is all. what about fighters who have been avoided? Do we just them to the wayside? Charley Burley, Archie Moore and Sam Langford were looked at as the best in their divisions for years without getting title shots till they were considered past their best. Margarito was considered the most dangerous fighter at welterweight, not Baldomir.

Please guys, everyone on this thread so far seems intelligent, dont get involved in knocking Floyds and Pacmans opponents. The opponents they beat made them p4p champs respectively.

Floyd fought the best Supper Feather, in Corrales, the best Lightweight in Castillo, the no2 light welter in Gatti, the ring Welter in Baldomir and the ring Light Middle in Oscar.

Pacquiao fought the best at each weight... someones already posted the guys he's beaten so im not going to repeat it. Also, Diaz was arguebly no2 lightweight, and was the WBC champion.

They both fought great fighters and the opponents they beat make them worthy of being p4p no1 in the world.

[larryx]

Please guys, everyone on this thread so far seems intelligent, dont get involved in knocking Floyds and Pacmans opponents. The opponents they beat made them p4p champs respectively.

Floyd fought the best Supper Feather, in Corrales, the best Lightweight in Castillo, the no2 light welter in Gatti, the ring Welter in Baldomir and the ring Light Middle in Oscar.

Pacquiao fought the best at each weight... someones already posted the guys he's beaten so im not going to repeat it. Also, Diaz was arguebly no2 lightweight, and was the WBC champion.

They both fought great fighters and the opponents they beat make them worthy of being p4p no1 in the world.

spot on..both earned their#1 spot..im giving credit to both of these great fighters

[Left Hook Tua]

lol..im not betting on that fight..i never bet on floyd....

i didn't bet on pac this past fight.

i've been losing all my bets lately......i didn't want to jinx him......

[larryx]

i didn't bet on pac this past fight.

i've been losing all my bets lately......i didn't want to jinx him......

yea im supersticous....ive been losing my bets also