Should Calzaghe retire?

[Wales08]

Up to him, if his heart is there then do it, if not call it a day.

[j.razor]

I think he should... what about you?

yeah, all the wack fighters should leave...

[a-raines21]

if he retires withought fighting jermain taylor and chad dawson, i think its fair to say his decisions are similar to floyd mayweather's.

[johnm is...]

How? Because I just received an email from Joe himself.

psst... You forgot to put that he doesn't like the guys posts in your email.

[medium-deek]

I would like him to stick around for a bit longer because he is a credit to British boxing... but if his heart isn't in it then I would rather him to retire than fight against his will (well not against his will but you get what i mean). Also, I think that if Calzaghe does have another fight or two... it should be with Chad Dawson rather than Carl Froch... Dawson deserves it more.

When Dawson's name was first suggested, I thought, give me a break. He hasn't proved anything. But I really want Joe to fight on so, hey, if its Dawson, then so be it!!!!

[Squabbles94806]

You know what? i don't think i've ever watched a Calzaghe fight from beginning to end. So it really doesn't matter if he retires or not. I just keep up with this guy's career. I haven't decided if i'd pay to watch him fight. I think it depends who he's fighting.

[Drunk Punch]

if he retires withought fighting jermain taylor and chad dawson, i think its fair to say his decisions are similar to floyd mayweather's.

Except Mayweather retired at 29 arguably way before his physical prime and Calzaghe is surely a few years past his prime.

[Pullcounter]

I think he should... what about you?

if he's not gonna rematch hopkins or fight dawson he might as well retire.

[Boxing_Girl23]

even though the first fight with Hopkins was ****ty, is was close, and I think he should give him a rematch and if he wins again then retire.