Floyd Mayweather Jr. - Is a Return Good For Boxing?

[badboypeenoy]

if you think pac is the best then he has to fight floyd, but I doubt he gets by hatton

If Mayweather is the best, prove it by fighting the best competition there is (which would be Margarito, Cotto and Wiliams) not somebody from a lower weightclass. You didn't see Mayweather and Roy Jones Jr. fight for P4P #1 status did you?

[Grand Champ]

Isn't DLH Floyd's biggest most impressive win? Yet you somehow managed to give Pac ZERO credit for beating Oscar. Funny how that works.

You could say that, however, even Freddy Roach and ODLH said that he just wasn't the same after a rather poor performance against Steve Forbes.

[badboypeenoy]

well the experts thought he was the best in the sport.... so **** what you think

The same experts who thought Oscar dela Hoya's going to walk over Pacquiao? This doesn't change the fact that Mayweather's boring.

[start11]

Well, PBF will be remembered as one of the best maybe... but the problem is many people are not yet satisfied with the greatness he has since there are still top contenders in a weight class he proclaimed himself as on top... And now if ever Pac-man wins against hatton in a more convincing way in a weight where hatton dominates, i'd say after that that pac-man is better than floyd... But for know I still believe that floyd's style is superior than pac-man... The only difference is that pac-man is more exciting to watch...

If floyd and pac-man fights, it would be one of the best fight in a decade and will be a legend... But unfortunately if ever floyd returns to boxing and after that fight retires again, i agree with the article, its not really good for boxing...

Pac-man now is an emerging superstar of boxing... He only need to defeat hatton in a more convincing way than what floyd did... If that happens, floyd must better stay retired and pac-man's next opponent must be top WW that floyd didn't fight...

[archermac X]

He'll only fight Pacquiao because Pacquiao's smaller. No way is he fighting again (especially against the likes of Margarito, Williams and ever Cotto)...he's too chicken for that. He'll just collect his millions, alienate moer fans because of his boring style and go back to hybernation after dealing the sport of boxing another Mayweather vs. Baldomir.

I'm not even sure if he's got the balls to face Pacquiao. Anyway, if he does, no way the fight's gonna end up like Mayweather-Baldomir. Pac is light years above Baldomir in speed and skills. Mayweather's gonna lose his 0 this time and end up being Pretty Black n' Blue.

[archermac X]

Yep that sure is...

Got that one, dude.

[a-raines21]

The same experts who thought Oscar dela Hoya's going to walk over Pacquiao? This doesn't change the fact that Mayweather's boring.

so u would rather watch gatti get his ass whooped? i mean he sucks, but hes not boring???? maybe he should be crownd king because hes the best at blocking with his face......... it doesnt matter how u win, as long as you do..... boring or not, hed kick your ass

[a-raines21]

I'm not even sure if he's got the balls to face Pacquiao. Anyway, if he does, no way the fight's gonna end up like Mayweather-Baldomir. Pac is light years above Baldomir in speed and skills. Mayweather's gonna lose his 0 this time and end up being Pretty Black n' Blue.

lol..... pac-man is good..... but he has hard times when ppl box him as oppose to fight him.... floyd is the ultimate boxer, hes faster than pac-man, has more power, is more accurate and gets hit less....... floyd would come out victorious in that fight

[a-raines21]

If Mayweather is the best, prove it by fighting the best competition there is (which would be Margarito, Cotto and Wiliams) not somebody from a lower weightclass. You didn't see Mayweather and Roy Jones Jr. fight for P4P #1 status did you?

how long have you been watching boxing? im just wondering...... im guessing ur in your mid 20s, so its just a shame that im much younger than you, but my understanding of the sport is so much higher than yours..... your like larry merchant

[5punchcombo]

Floyd needs to stay retired. Only coming out of retirement for a big payday? **** that, He should earn his paydays like all the top welters have been trying to do.

This spoiled bastard got a lucky payday and now will only fight for big money not taking on all the best?

Soon as this lil filipino moved up for one fight he finds it necessary to come out of retirement. What a pussie move.

Only way he earns a big payday and or respect as the P4P best is if he fights

Cotto or Margarito the two BEST Welters in the game and wins