Is Margarito TOO BIG for welterweights?

[weekender101]

If you make the weight, how the hell can you be 'too big' ?!

[MOREBASS]

Definitely not too big. He's a tall welter, but as long as he can make the weight limit, its fair game.

[120]

If you make the weight, how the hell can you be 'too big' ?!

most boxers make weight because of special weight draining techniques and that leave some people in classes they don't belong to hence some are FORCED to move up in weight as they just can make the weight any more

[MANGLER]

We back on this **** again?

[ANDROID_DOES]

Is shaq too big for centers, is pac too fast for welters, is lebron too big too be a guard? Does tiger woods hit the bar too far for golfers?

[MOREBASS]

most boxers make weight because of special weight draining techniques and that leave some people in classes they don't belong to hence some are FORCED to move up in weight as they just can make the weight any more

Again, if you can make weight on the day of the weigh in, which is 24 hours before the actual fight. Then why would you say somme people are in classes they don't belong ?

If the weight loss is affecting the fighter's performance, then most likely he will opt to move up a division.

[LoloChivas]

he has made the weight so according to current boxing rules no. BUT go back to same day weight-in and that will fix the problem u are trying to prove here

n how many boxers would going back to same day weigh-ins effect? almost all of them. So why is tony the only one being talked about?

[Sweet Pea 50]

[QUOTE=LoloChivas;4530375]n how many boxers would going back to same day weigh-ins effect? almost all of them. So why is tony the only one being talked about?[/QUOTE]

Well, we could go on about the 2 billion threads about PWill at WW.....

[120]

n how many boxers would going back to same day weigh-ins effect? almost all of them. So why is tony the only one being talked about?

i'm not slamming tony at all. He makes the weight so i don't have a problem whatsoever. I'm slamming the boxing committees in general. close to 50-70% of boxers would have to move up but that's the point. It would be without advantages. you wouldn't see people like celestino caballero fighting at 122

[AntDawg]

i saw the judah fight but i wasnt particularly impressed with his power tbh, like i said i havent seen many of his fights

he always looks to be in great shape though, no denying that

Not that one punch knockout power but he can hurt you with a combination. I believe he hurt Margarito in the early rounds of their fight.