PACFANS:Name all the GREAT PRIME FIGHTERS manny has defeated Convincingly!!

[kenso]

So you have accepted that answer. So do you know any active great fighter who convincingly defeated another great prime fighter? I'll be waiting for your answer.

just cause i can :

b-hops wins over pavlik(debatable on primeness), and trinidad
pavliks wins over jermain taylor
mayweathers win over hatton
vasquez over marquez and vice versa
marco antonio barrera over hamed
pacquiao over barrera and marquez
etc......

look, great fighters "primes" are generally short periods. just because every fighter pac has fought was not in is 100% prime does not mean that his wins are meaningless. MAB WAS at his peak at 29 years old, and to this day is still a force to be reckoned with. some people feel that barrera may have beaten marquez.

the REAL question you need to ask yourself is, could another fighter have went through pacs resume and came out not only with the same record, but knocking people out in the same fashion that he did?

my answer is no.

dont over shadow pacs accomplishments cause you wanna be a punk and discredit some of his victories with typical anti fanboy excuses. you can have your opinions about him, but if you dont think hes a good fighter, you are an absolute moron and do not know boxing.

[Pepe Smith]

No I'm just pointing out how ****** you are. Floyd is a great fighter and an all time great but I can discredit his biggest wins using your flawed logic.

Corrales - weight drained six footer fighting at 130
Genaro Hernandez - Old and got beaten by Dela hoya
Arturo gAtti - too many wars and had a trilogy with ward
DLH - Got beat by sturm and Hopkins
etc.

Qouted my own post so that the bastard can see my reply

[xcaret]

I've said this for years. Manny is really really overated. He lost to erik and jmm marquez beat him in their prime. Manny either fights fighters that are drained or past their prime

so ***in true thats sickening.

[Benny Leonard]

marco antonio barrera...

Not sure he was so fresh: he was in two wars with Morales; wasn't he?

JMM was in his prime and he is a very good fighter.


Either way; Manny is the most exciting fighter on the scene and he brings it every match. And has solid wins on his resume.

[shadeyfizzle]

thats EXACTLY the response i was expecting...EXACTLY..changing the subject is simply all u can do..lord knows u cant give me a list of PRIME FIGHTERS that manny has defeated convincingly. i TOOK OUT EVERY PACFAN ON HERE RIGHT NOW ON... ONE...FELL..SWOOP.

Chatchai Sasakul was the #1rated and lineal ring flyweight champion when Manny beat him.

Lehlonolo Ledwaba was the ring's #1 rated bantamweight when Manny beat him

Barrera was the #3p4p fighter in the world when he got demolished by a Manny who was coming up in weight for the 1st time. A feat that not even a Kevin Kelley, Derick Gainer, Naseem Hamed or Erik Morales could claim.

Erik Morales, past prime or not was still the #2 rated jr lightweight when Pac KO'd him.

Oscar Delahoya, past prime, dehydrated, or whatever other excuse you wanna use. is still a 10x world champion. And Manny Pacquiao is the only former flyweight champion to ever beat a former welterweight champion.

[xcaret]

pacquiao will only be remembered as the fighter that beat past and shot fighters by boxing experts... really sad.

[robjr]

whats with this goblin guy?

[kenso]

so ***in true thats sickening.

your opinion is automatically disregarded since you are probably the biggest pac hater on the boards. i remember you CRYYYYYYYYYYYYYING when pac beat de la hoya, a fight, if i remember correctly, you picked pac to lose by brutal KO!

[HappyBoxingFan]

so ***in true thats sickening.

Why can't we just agree that JMM and Pacquiao are both GREAT top p4p fighters. I mean, it's the truth. So, let's get past all of this and look foward to the inevitable final chapter.

[Benny Leonard]

Name a great Prime fighter Floyd beat convincingly

Undefeated Diego Corrales