Should James Toney retire?

[Silencers]

It's time for him to hang them up.

[KostyaTszyu44]

Toney should have retired along time ago that old ****. Hes lazy and sloppy in the ring and doesn't have the power anymore. hes just doing it for the money.

no hes not, hes doing it because its a way of life for him and he loves it....but he needs to retire, i love the guy and i know he wants to keep fighting but its i his best interests, its not like he has anything left to prove, hes a shoo in HoFer and will consistently be named as one of the best ever in the cruiserweight and supermiddleweight divisions, and probably deserves to be ranked in the top 40-60 boxers of all time

[cuzfozzy]

toney loves boxing more than wladimiar ...
wladimir doesnt like to fight .... thats why
last nights fight was so boring

[MANGLER]

Dude ain't got it in him to win anotha title. He should call it.

[cuzfozzy]

what i dont get is why they chose to fight rahman
the guy just lost to toney

[madskills]

Ah Toney, true Madskills, time to hang it up though.

[Ian_ST24i]

Toney won't retire until he looks like Butterbean!

[Dan...]

Obviously James should retire. There is no logical counter-argument.

[Derranged]

yeah but rahman was stopped only cos he stopped punching back
he wasn't in any real danger other than just being a punching bag

The fight against Toney was stopped because of a CUT genious. Just be thankful Toney will never fight Wladimir...........

[Allucard]

Toney won't retire until he looks like Butterbean!

now that you mention it he kinda looks like butterbean (just saw a butterbean fight in k1) only the wrong colors, even his face and expression are similar to beans...