Should James Toney retire?

[1SILVA]

James Toney barely defeated a B heavyweight in Fres Oquendo. A Hall-of-Fame great, it is in my opinion time for him to retire. He is no longer a great fighter and if he is not careful, he will wind up getting. Does everyone agree with this assessment?

[Skylight]

He didn't beat Fres, they gave him the scorecards.

He doesn't look like a threat to most heavyweights, he should hang them up, he has done enough.

[Welter_Skelter]

I agreed with you 4 years ago..

[crazyjames]

Toney should have retired along time ago that old ****. Hes lazy and sloppy in the ring and doesn't have the power anymore. hes just doing it for the money.

[J.R.]

The words **** YES spring to mind.

[Slotff]

Whomever voted "No" hates James Toney.

[ACHlLLES]

Whomever voted "No" hates James Toney.

I can bet my life it was that dumb cuzfozzy poster

[cuzfozzy]

no it wasn't me

but yeah. why should he retire. no one has beaten him up yet

he almost knocked out rahman in 4 rounds well he actually
did cos rahman quit

wladimir took longer to beat rahman ... rahman never went
down by the way

[Slotff]

no it wasn't me

but yeah. why should he retire. no one has beaten him up yet

he almost knocked out rahman in 4 rounds well he actually
did cos rahman quit

wladimir took longer to beat rahman ... rahman never went
down by the way

Klitschko did knock Rahman down in the 6th with a few left hooks.

[cuzfozzy]

yeah but rahman was stopped only cos he stopped punching back
he wasn't in any real danger other than just being a punching bag