POLL: Rate Joe Calzaghe's Resume (1-10)

[DarchinyFAN]

I'd have to know the standards.
Who would be close to a 10?

[VERSION1 (V1)]

6.9.............

[Oasis_Lad]

I'd have to know the standards.
Who would be close to a 10?

I'd regard Ali as being a 10.

Wins on his resume:

Frazier x2
Foreman
Norton x2
Liston x2
Archie Moore
Floyd Patterson x2
George Chuvalo
Jerry Quarry x2
Earnie Shavers
Ron Lyle
Jimmy Young
Oscar Boneva
Cleveland Williams

And those are just off the top of my head.

[DarchinyFAN]

meh I just said 6 figuring 5 was average.
I could probably be convinced in a point either direction

[Sick/]

It's a seven.

[El Dominicano]

****** of me to have said 6, atleast 7.

[lest26]

9 unbeaten and did the best he could, if the likes of hopkins and rjj did not want to know when cal was in his prime there aint alot you can do, plus when he did fight them Hops was still and still is very good, but i remember whenever joe was leading up to a fight scores of critics and genraly american fight fans would right him off and even after he had beaten them convincingly they still would right him off, dont hate ppl

[NakiFan]

Ring #2, 10 year champ, ring champ at 2 weights, 46-0, and 9 people give him a ****ing 1!

I gave it an 8

[DrewWoodside]

Ring #2, 10 year champ, ring champ at 2 weights, 46-0, and 9 people give him a ****ing 1!

I gave it an 8

The group of posters who gave him a 1 are a$%holes but the group who gave him a 10 aren't much better.

[Technical_Skill]

LMAO at some of these poll results, didnt this guy fight carlos christie?

And the usual suspects still give him 10.

So he has an equal resume to that of Ali?