POLL: Rate Joe Calzaghe's Resume (1-10)

[KESSLER]

Bump...............

[hammerhiem]

If i made a thread called rate Zab Judah's resume, then another "rate Hoya's resume" and repeat for all top 15 p4p fighters you would see clearly why Joe is overrated.

Judah has never even been close to top 15 P4P....

[bsrizpac]

In the present era, he gets an 8 from me, I still don't know who all the haters think he didn't fight at SMW...

If you compaire it to the 70's he'd probably only get a 6 but it's not the 70's and if we are compairing to the 70's none of the fighters today would get more than 7/10.

8 = shameless cheerleading.

[Pullcounter]

Judah has never even been close to top 15 P4P....

hm... is judah's resume better than calzaghe's???

yeah he lost, but he lost to a lot of good fighters... calz beat everyone he's fought but they're all bums or senior citizens or shot fighters.

[bsrizpac]

Judah has never even been close to top 15 P4P....

http://www.bloodyknux.com/forum/showthread.php?t=1987

Wrong again. Calzaghe fans need to watch boxing longer and more than just Joe's career.

[Pico Hollywood]

voted...............................

[roundingace]

4. Sorry. Goodbye Joe, fade away and hopefully, your fans will too.

[Hook]

Ill give it 5

[nathan_nall]

...............1

Thats a personal agenda against Calzaghe. Andrew "Kid Thunder" has at least a 2 resume.

[mick66]

Anyone who has voted 5 or below, is showing themselves to be a friggin ******..