James Toney Wins Controversial Decision Over Oquendo

[KostyaTszyu44]

it wasnt a robbery, it was a reasonably close fight

i thought oquendo may have just won it....but i guess a toney win is fair enough....a draw was probably the best result

[KostyaTszyu44]

He wont stand a chance against a top 10 heavy

hence why i said he needs to retire

[Golden Boy 360]

hence why i said he needs to retire

yeah he should retire...so should roy jones jr...holyfield..

[Floyd Sinclair]

Im a HUGE fan of Toney

but not a fan of injustice

Fres won the fight...

fair and square..

stop with the robberies

He got ****ing robbed!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!


Damn i hate this ****!!!!!

i gotta agree with you. Toneys probably my favorite boxer, right there with bernard hopkins but he didnt win this fight. I do believe if he was willing to commit to a better diet, and more training hes still got sumthin left.

He looked flabby and sick like larry holmes. He was more of a comedian in this fight then a boxer. But i dont think at any point he got hurt. Hes gotta lose 10-15 pounds if hes gonna fight again. He'll be quicker and able to throw and land more of them counter punches.

[totalstranga]

I love it! yeah Fres was robbed, but Toney is my man so I'm glad he won. But if thats the best he can do, he should fight Malik Scott next, def. not a top 10 HW

[The Hammer]

It was a clear win for Oquendo, 115-112 on my card.

[roujinziro]

Toney is an old school fighter, but he's done and should hang up the gloves.

[Kastrioti]

I put money on Toney, but after the fight I was sure I lost it. It was close, but I was pretty shocked. When I heard the last scorecard was 114-113 I knew they were gonna give it to Toney.

[EDD1]

tony is waisting Goosen's time

[loui_ludwig]

I don't beleived Toney is done/shot. He just needs to lose weight, worked in his conditioning. If he wants a title shot, he needs to train hard, like how Klitskos, Holyfield, or Lewis.