LOL @ anyone thinking JoeC is p4p number 1

[Mr. Philadel]

I don't see how that is a ridiculous comment. If Floyd came back to fight Pacquiao I am picking Manny to beat him for sure.

don't be crazy....be smart man! Floyd beats Pac all day......the ONLY 2 dudes with more than a chance to beat Floyd are Marg and PW....thats it!!

[Dirk Diggler UK]

So Joe dominates and embarrasses Roy yet gets no credit cos Roys a washed up shot fighter. Yet Manny does the same to Oscar and suddenly hes undisputed P4P no1 and anyone who disagrees is ******.

Ok then

[BlackHat]

So Joe dominates and embarrasses Roy yet gets no credit cos Roys a washed up shot fighter. Yet Manny does the same to Oscar and suddenly hes undisputed P4P no1 and anyone who disagrees is ******.

Ok then

So JOe is still your no.1 p4p?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

So Joe dominates and embarrasses Roy yet gets no credit cos Roys a washed up shot fighter. Yet Manny does the same to Oscar and suddenly hes undisputed P4P no1 and anyone who disagrees is ******.

Ok then

i didnt recall jones having a 5inch reach and 4inch height advantage...nor do i remember manny getting dropped by his 'shot' opponent....


making a legend go 'no mas' > going 12 over a punchless roy

[badboypeenoy]

Prior to the fight a lot of ppl on here had Joe Calzaghe at p4p number 1.

As ridiculous as this was before yesterday, surely now this type of thinking is over right? I mean, that **** is complete madness.

Even if Calzaghe beat Dawson and Johnson and then rematched Hopkins and beat him again I don't think he overtakes Manny at number 1.

Well, he could do what Manny did, jump two divisions and face a legend. Say Calzaghe vs. Lewis at a catch-weight and Calzaghe gives Lewis a beatdown

[Dan...]

So Joe dominates and embarrasses Roy yet gets no credit cos Roys a washed up shot fighter. Yet Manny does the same to Oscar and suddenly hes undisputed P4P no1 and anyone who disagrees is ******.

Ok then

Anyone who thinks Joe's win over Roy holds more significance than Manny's win last night is a moron, seriously.

Truth is Manny has four wins that are better than any of Joe's.

[JaNnO]

Tell you the truth, I thought Marquez beat Pacquiao both times. I'm not hating on dude and I don't like Calzaghe. I'm just saying, in his last five fights he's beaten Lacy, Bika, Kessler, Hopkins and Jones and he's done it without a whole lot of controversy. If someone wanted to rank him higher than 3 it's really not that big of a deal.

And yeah Gillie was a ghostwriter for all of Cash Money.

jmm is overrated. his biggest achievement was beating up an old casa and a draw against pacman. he might have given pac 2 good fights but still came out short in both. he's an excellent tactician but he doesn't deserve to be the #2 or #3 p4p ranking. joe-cal is def #2 and b-hop is at #3.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

i didnt recall jones having a 5inch reach and 4inch height advantage...nor do i remember manny getting dropped by his 'shot' opponent....


making a legend go 'no mas' > going 12 over a punchless roy

So Oscar is a legend and not shot. But Roy is shot, washed up, punchless etc.

I prefer to give bothy guys credit and stay consistent rather than promote horrible double standards but thats just me.

[JaNnO]

pac beats pbf. speed, power, heart, tenacity, improved boxing skills plus support of 90 million pinoys...pac is on top of the mountain right now...but i like your sig...those were awesome combos!

don't be crazy....be smart man! Floyd beats Pac all day......the ONLY 2 dudes with more than a chance to beat Floyd are Marg and PW....thats it!!

[Dan...]

pac beats pbf. speed, power, heart, tenacity, improved boxing skills plus support of 90 million pinoys...pac is on top of the mountain right now...but i like your sig...those were awesome combos!

Its funny how **** works. A few months ago I would have laughed at this comment. Now I think I agree with it.