what is oscar's best career win?

[MANGLER]

Vargas. His wins over Ike and Pea are too questionable, although on name power alone, Pea is obviously the greatest fighter he's beaten.

[King Koopa]

1. Fernando Vargas

[Sin City]

I'm not sure about that to be honest bro. Pernell looked absolutely terrible in his fight against Hurtado prior to the Oscar fight. Although I do accept that what Floyd fought was definately not a prime version of Oscar.

so you saying De La Hoya didn't look bad against Hopkins and Sturm?
Because he won against Mayorga (I like Mayorga but he is a limited fighter) that changes anything?

[EL HANDSOME]

A Roided up Sugar Shane Mosley.

[Dan...]

so you saying De La Hoya didn't look bad against Hopkins and Sturm?
Because he won against Mayorga (I like Mayorga but he is a limited fighter) that changes anything?

Pea looked terrible against Hurtado. He would have lost the fight had he not got lucky and landed big late.

I maintain that the version of Oscar that fought Floyd was not as shot as the one of Pea that fought Oscar. Pea was also fighting well outside his natural weight class.

Also, Oscar looked bad against Sturm because he barely trained and I don't think it is ever fair to say he looked bad against Bernard. He was holding his own against a much bigger man for several rounds before the size difference became too much.