Who deserves a higher p4p rating?

[-Swizzy-]

Well some ppl overrtate the cotto win, and look at ring ratings and don't think for themselves

agreed. marg shouldn't have got a shot at cotto in the first place. ppl say "well p-will lost to quintana" yeah well p-will avenged his loss and marg didn't avenge his lose to p-will plus he beat golden johnson and cintron before facing cotto. I don't think he deserved a shot at cotto more than p-will. Although I didn't mind the matchup cuz the cotto-marg fight was great, but as far as who deserved a shot at the ring title and who should be ranked higher on the p4p list, the answer is p-will.

[DiegoFuego]

uh let's see...

Williams beat Margarito

Williams fights in 3 different weight classes at the same time

If you voted Margarito, you must be Mexican or full of ****

[mellow_mood]

holly ****... it seems like we can debate this for decades... i didnt expect the poll to be that close...

I've always think that p4p rankings should be for fighters who move from weight to weight still dominating.... - as may, dlh, tito, nard, roy, manny pac,

for me .. i just cant have a boxer in a p4p list with out at least being a 2 division champion...

with that being said.. by my logic.... paul williams should be ahead..

[-Swizzy-]

holly ****... it seems like we can debate this for decades... i didnt expect the poll to be that close...

I've always think that p4p rankings should be for fighters who move from weight to weight still dominating.... - as may, dlh, tito, nard, roy, manny pac,

for me .. i just cant have a boxer in a p4p list with out at least being a 2 division champion...

with that being said.. by my logic.... paul williams should be ahead..

exactly. paul williams has accomplished more and thus should be higher on the list. as of right now, he isn't even ranked in the top 10 in the ring ratings and marg is like 6th or 7th.

and as far as debating goes, not much of a debate cuz the marg fans don't have any argument and you can see by the amount of posts supporting margarito in this thread.....ZERO.

[mellow_mood]

exactly. paul williams has accomplished more and thus should be higher on the list. as of right now, he isn't even ranked in the top 10 in the ring ratings and marg is like 6th or 7th.

and as far as debating goes, not much of a debate cuz the marg fans don't have any argument and you can see by the amount of posts supporting margarito in this thread.....ZERO.

yup!.. im with you in this one....

but. .hey that doesnt change the fact that I pick Margo over williams in their rematch!!...

but p4p.... williams definitly have an edge over marg... IMO

[egreezy]

its basically common sense, those that voted for margarito... something stopped them from using it

[-Swizzy-]

bump... just want to see if ppl still have the same sentiment for margarito.