Which WIN would help Margarito more? A win over SSM or The Punisher

[El Dominicano]

I'll make a poll

Take alot into consideration...It ain't just about the name.

I believe is no different from askin "Would a RJJ win have been better for JC then Chad"

[Left Hook Tua]

i think fighting paul would help a lot so people can shut up about the "ducking paul williams" bull****.

but...... shane mosley is a better win name-wise and legacy-wise for marg.

[Nacho_Analstain]

Paul Williams solely because he beat him.

[SalvaDominicano]

Let the voting begin. Of course, you know who my vote is

[Lazy Liberal]

Mosley as a name but Williams for respect

[Eric Holder]

Beating Shane does waaaay more for Tony, Shane's still a top 4 welter weight and a future hall of famer. Obviously Shane's carrer is on the down slope but he's still a bigger name than Paul.


if Paul goes on to be the p4p king that people on here swear that he's gonna be, and that's a big IF than the PWill fight would do more.

But right now all PWill has going for him is that he beat Tony(on an off night for Margarito) which puts Paul in the same "elite" class as Victor Lozoya and Rodney Jones

[Left Hook Tua]

Paul Williams solely because he beat him.

in a year or two paul will still be there.

it's either now or never for a chance at adding shane to the resume.

[Lazy Liberal]

Beating Shane does waaaay more for Tony, Shane's still a top 4 welter weight and a future hall of famer. Obviously Shane's carrer is on the down slope but he's still a bigger name than Paul.


if Paul goes on to be the p4p king that people on here swear that he's gonna be, and that's a big IF than the PWill fight would do more.

But right now all PWill has going for him is that he beat Tony(on an off night for Margarito) which puts Paul in the same "elite" class as Victor Lozoya and Rodney Jones

not an off night, Paul controlled throughout and Tony only came on late, real late. Be honest.

[Lazy Liberal]

not an off night, Paul controlled throughout and Tony only came on late, real late. Be honest.

Tony himself said that he won the fight and that he was robbed, not talk from someone who had an off night.

[MANGLER]

As a fan I want an UD WW champ, and that means Pwill. From a business standpoint, SSM is mos def the bigger name.