Who defends Marg's decision to fight Mosley instead of Williams?

[Pullcounter]

Yes, but Mayweather never fought the guys who challenged him,

Antonio did.

See the difference?

yeah, but isn't it ironic that marg fans use mayweather lines? doesn't it make you feel dirty?

[deevel79]

nah, it proves that pwill is better than marg.

neither marg nor pwill can claim to be the #1 welterweight until they fight again.

Fair enough!

[Pullcounter]

No it doesn't because the fact remains, out of the 3, Paul, Migs, and Tony,


Margarito is the only one with these names on his resume.

Williams, Cotto, Clottey, Cintron, and soon to be Shane.

Miguel only has Tony and Shane.

Paul only has Tony.

rating the WW division in this way is worthless because no one is willing to fight pwill.

[Derranged]

To me its whatever. I rather see him fight Williams, but IF Team Margarito made an offer for the immediate rematch and Team Williams refused, then that's Paul and/or Goosens fault. I dont defend his decision but Im not gonna criticize him for it.

[Vasyl’s dad]

yeah, but isn't it ironic that marg fans use mayweather lines?

Not really.


Tony isn't retired, nor did he say, "you'll get your shot", and then fade into the Las Vegas night without facing who he said he was.


See the difference?

[CreamMRS]

This is really a non-discussion, but so many people here want to act like ****ing women. Both Margarito and Williams are badasses, and I really don't think either of them are afraid of anyone else, much less each other. There are REAL reasons for them not fighting just yet, namely money issues, the marketability of a rematch, and higher priority fights like the Cotto rematch. PWill is understandably upset because the guy that he beat last year is now the man, and is in position for money fights, so he's running his mouth a lot to get that attention, but he's just kind of SOL for the time being. I think the FIGHT WILL HAPPEN in late 2009, so long as Margarito beats mosley and then cotto, which is not guaranteed. So just relax your vaginas and see what happens.

Margarito has beaten Clottey, Cotto, Cintronx2, and will be favored to beat Mosley... He is basically one fight away(a rematch with Williams from cleaning out one of the deepest divisions in boxing. That is unless you believe that he needs to beat Berto too, but he is arguably very green.

[Vasyl’s dad]

rating the WW division in this way is worthless because no one is willing to fight pwill.

How about Margarito already did and Paul passed up on an immediate rematch?

Or how about like I've said before,

there is no number 1 welterweight due to the cluster**** we have now because of that initial refusal.

Had Paul given that immediate rematch, things would be much clearer today.


But, he didn't, and lost, further muddying things up.

[Pullcounter]

Not really.


Tony isn't retired, nor did he say, "you'll get your shot", and then fade into the Las Vegas night without facing who he said he was.


See the difference?

yeah, but marg isn't even saying to pwill 'you'll get your shot'... he's just ducking plain and simple

[Pullcounter]

How about Margarito already did and Paul passed up on an immediate rematch?

Or how about like I've said before,

there is no number 1 welterweight due to the cluster**** we have now because of that initial refusal.

Had Paul given that immediate rematch, things would be much clearer today.


But, he didn't, and lost, further muddying things up.

yeah, but how about marg and pwill fight and clear things up, problem solved... oh yeah, marg don't want nothing to do with pwill.

[Pullcounter]

This is really a non-discussion, but so many people here want to act like ****ing women. Both Margarito and Williams are badasses, and I really don't think either of them are afraid of anyone else, much less each other. There are REAL reasons for them not fighting just yet, namely money issues, the marketability of a rematch, and higher priority fights like the Cotto rematch. PWill is understandably upset because the guy that he beat last year is now the man, and is in position for money fights, so he's running his mouth a lot to get that attention, but he's just kind of SOL for the time being. I think the FIGHT WILL HAPPEN in late 2009, so long as Margarito beats mosley and then cotto, which is not guaranteed. So just relax your vaginas and see what happens.

Margarito has beaten Clottey, Cotto, Cintronx2, and will be favored to beat Mosley... He is basically one fight away(a rematch with Williams from cleaning out one of the deepest divisions in boxing. That is unless you believe that he needs to beat Berto too, but he is arguably very green.

yeah, but marg hasn't cleaned out the ww division until he fights and beats williams