just scored Castillo vs Mayweather 1

[CottoIsBackBtch]

Castillo won... Floyd has a BS Zero.

[Burner]

Castillo won... Floyd has a BS Zero.

and Cotto quit on his knees like a ***** against Margarito.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Ive scored it a couple times and always have Castillo winning. It was obviously close so its harsh to say it was a robbery. But the judges cards were what made it shocking and how far they had Mayweather winning by.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

and Cotto quit on his knees like a ***** against Margarito.

No offence but at least he fought Margarito.

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Mayweather won, haters are very desperate

A robbery is when you can't make a case for a fighter that he won the fight

eg Whitaker/JCC Holyfield/Lewis

You called Hopkins vs Calzaghe a robbery.

[Ch@mpBox@PR]

Just Watch the fight again and theres no way that Floyd won that fight, the worst that it could it been was a draw. I had it 115-111 for Castillo. from the 4th round on Castillo gave him a whooping!!!!!

1.Mayweather 10-9
2.Mayweather 10-9
3.Mayweather 10-9
4.Mayweather 10-9
5.Castillo 10-9
6.Castillo 10-9
7.Castillo 10-9
8.Castillo 10-9
9.Even 9-9
10.Castillo 10-8
11.Castillo 10-9
12.Castillo 10-9
115-111

[mt102819]

Yes, Castillo clearly defeated Mayweather eight rounds to four, but was robbed by the judges that night in Las Vegas. Everybody looked surprised when the scorecards were read, including Mayweather.

[Poet682006]

Ey guys that fight was 8 years ago.

Who gives a shyt...Let it go..Castillo has.

People are still talking about the scoring in the first Louis - Walcott fight and that was 62 years ago: 8 years is nothing. This is what REAL boxing fans do: Talk about big fights and controversies no matter how long gulf of time has grown. Personally I wouldn't have it any other way; especially at time when the biggest fight of the year features a washed up Welterweight fighting a FEATHERWEIGHT ffs.

Poet

[Poet682006]

Ive scored it a couple times and always have Castillo winning. It was obviously close so its harsh to say it was a robbery. But the judges cards were what made it shocking and how far they had Mayweather winning by.

It's another case where outside considerations influence the judges scoring: If the round is close they'll find a way to score it for the "money" fighter, in this case Mayweather. Refs do this **** too: Watch the first Bowe - Golota fight where the ref warns and penalizes Golota repeatedly for low blows while completely ignoring Bowe's blatant rabbit punching (a far more serious and FAR more dangerous foul). Bowe was the fighter that brought in the big bucks and who the hell was Golota?

Poet

[Poet682006]

Just Watch the fight again and theres no way that Floyd won that fight, the worst that it could it been was a draw. I had it 115-111 for Castillo. from the 4th round on Castillo gave him a whooping!!!!!

1.Mayweather 10-9
2.Mayweather 10-9
3.Mayweather 10-9
4.Mayweather 10-9
5.Castillo 10-9
6.Castillo 10-9
7.Castillo 10-9
8.Castillo 10-9
9.Even 9-9
10.Castillo 10-8
11.Castillo 10-9
12.Castillo 10-9
115-111

I think I'll dust it off and watch it again this weekend and score it.

Poet