just scored Castillo vs Mayweather 1

[warp1432]

I thought Castillo won the 4th and lost the 8th. 8th is a close round, but you really got to pay attention especially because you see Mayweather blocking his shots and landing some really nice counters that get him the 10-8 instead of the 9-9.

[mayweather4life]

1 more thing

i also doubt the figth was fixed.. it wasn't a big event and wasn't on ppv.. just for those who thought the judges were paid or something.. I had it 114-113 for floyd i think.. its been a while since i watched it but everytime i have floyd winning.. one time i had it a draw though

[deliveryman]

Regardless it was a VERY close fight, and a lot of the rounds could easily be scored for either fighter, which is why the scorecards posted are so volitile, 115-112 for Castillo, 116-111 for Mayweather. You can make a case for either fighter winning the fight, and that what happens when there's a very close fight. There wasn't no robbery.

All the matters is, is that Floyd gave Castillo an immediate rematch and won soundly the second time around.

[Jim Jeffries]

Whoever you thought won, there is no way to legitimately score 8 or 9 rounds for Mayweather, the way the judges had it. I personally had it 114-112 for Castillo, which is hardly a robbery, but there didn't seem to be a way for Castillo to win in those judges eyes.

[Burner]

Ey guys that fight was 8 years ago.

Who gives a shyt...Let it go..Castillo has.

[warp1432]

Whoever you thought won, there is no way to legitimately score 8 or 9 rounds for Mayweather, the way the judges had it. I personally had it 114-112 for Castillo, which is hardly a robbery, but there didn't seem to be a way for Castillo to win in those judges eyes.

Well rounds were close so if you really really wanted to, I guess you could make a case for 115-111 Mayweather. Not sure how the **** someone got 116-111 though. That's crazy.

I have no problem with people who saying Castillo won, but it wasn't the robbery people make it out to be and I think Mayweather deserved the decision.

[boxing_great]

IT WAS clear castillo won that fight.There were some rounds Castillo clearly won, for which he wasn't awarded!

[bobbito]

castillo got robbed i had it 6 for castillo 4 mayweather and 2 even..one judge even had it 116-111 for mayweather.

i cant remember what i scored the fight...but i remember i had castillo winning by 3 points i think...but floyd handled in the rematch...

[Flawless 2]

Mayweather won, haters are very desperate

A robbery is when you can't make a case for a fighter that he won the fight

eg Whitaker/JCC Holyfield/Lewis

[mayweather4life]

my official scorecard.

round 1: Mayweather 10-9
round 2: Mayweather 10-9
round 3: Mayweather 10-9
round 4: Mayweather 10-9
round 5: Mayweather 10-9
round 6: Castillio 10-9
round 7: Castillio 10-9
round 8: Mayweather 10-8
round 9: Castillio 10-9
Round 10: Even 9-9
Round 11: Castillio 10-9
Round 12: Castillio 10-9

Total: 114-112 Mayweather

Look at both faces after the fight... HBO just completely forgot about what mayweather did and focused on castillio the whole fight. 39-0 no questions asked