could calzaghe be a top 10 heavyweight?

[-Swizzy-]

what a load of rubbish. he would beat most of them with ease and have problems with vitali,wlad,chagaev,haye but all are very winable.

chagaev, haye and small heavyweights he he'd beat these. wlad is 50/50 as i said and id favor vitali every so slightly at 60/40

calzaghe would lose to Tye Fields. and I'm not even joking.

[Equilibrium]

i think wlad vs joe is 50/50, joe wins if he dances and uses his fast jab and stamina to win. with footwork. wlad wins if he blasts joe out which would be very hard to do.

[Poet682006]

You know, considering how badly the Heavyweights suck right now and how an out of shape, washed up, blown up former Middleweight (James Toney) was able to make a run maybe Calzaghe WOULD make a top-ten Heavyweight. That really doesn't say anything to Joe's credit, only how God aweful the Heavies are right now.

Poet

[Squirrel]

Oh man, I would LOVE to see Calzaghe vs Tua/Ibeabuchi from their match-up.

[CaRnAgEViOLaToR]

why not, the heavyweights are crap

[Get_Loud740]

This is about riduclous.....
I think Joe gets way to much damn credit for so little...
Someone posted how ****ty the heavyweights are right now,which is completely true.
I give Joe no credit as of now,he is hyped up to be alot more than what i think he is...

[paul750]

You know, considering how badly the Heavyweights suck right now and how an out of shape, washed up, blown up former Middleweight (James Toney) was able to make a run maybe Calzaghe WOULD make a top-ten Heavyweight. That really doesn't say anything to Joe's credit, only how God aweful the Heavies are right now.

Poet

Toney is a tough son of a gun though. He's shown he can take a heavyweight punch. He is also incredibly skilled of course. Calzaghe doesn't seem like the type of guy who could take a huge heavyweight punch - he just seems too small. Most of the heavyweights are awful though, and anything is possible. He might be able to beat a few top 20-30 guys. If only the heavyweights had his conditioning.

[TheGreatAli]

This is about riduclous.....
I think Joe gets way to much damn credit for so little...
Someone posted how ****ty the heavyweights are right now,which is completely true.
I give Joe no credit as of now,he is hyped up to be alot more than what i think he is...

Aww you from Ohio little boy? Still upset about the ass whooping Pavlik got?

[MANGLER]

This **** is ******ed. No way Joe C would fight at HW.

[MWMerlino]

lol

this is the kind of thread that properly highlights the level of intelligence on this board.