could calzaghe be a top 10 heavyweight?

[larryx]

what a load of rubbish. he would beat most of them with ease and have problems with vitali,wlad,chagaev,haye but all are very winable.

chagaev, haye and small heavyweights he he'd beat these. wlad is 50/50 as i said and id favor vitali every so slightly at 60/40

yea i know whats wrong with these guys..we all know hatton could beat hopkins also

[paul750]

I say let him test himself against someone like Marcus Rhode first, then we can get a better idea of how he'd do in the division. And then maybe fight Tye Fields after that to prepare himself for the giants.

[Underdog82]

what's your list if he fought there

1. vitali klitschko
2. joe calzaghe
3. wladimir klitschko
4. ruslan chagaev
5. david haye
6. sultan ibragimov
7. nikolai valuev
8. alexander povetkin
9. samuel peter
10. tony thompson

only one i can see beating him is vitali, but calzaghe has chance to beat him because vitali is old and will tire.

Calzaghe loses to everyone on this list except Samuel peter and Thompson. He would UD both of them.

[Chase8400]

what a load of rubbish. he would beat most of them with ease and have problems with vitali,wlad,chagaev,haye but all are very winable.

chagaev, haye and small heavyweights he he'd beat these. wlad is 50/50 as i said and id favor vitali every so slightly at 60/40

I'm just curious about how you can honestly give Calzaghe a snowmans chance in hell with Wladimir Klitschko? Are you being serious here? Because I cannot bring myself to believe somebody can be this ignorant to boxing ethics.

[larryx]

Calzaghe loses to everyone on this list except Samuel peter and Thompson. He would UD both of them.

lol sam peter would seriously hurt joe

[marco363]

I'm just curious about how you can honestly give Calzaghe a snowmans chance in hell with Wladimir Klitschko? Are you being serious here? Because I cannot bring myself to believe somebody can be this ignorant to boxing ethics.

better speed, footwork, good chin, reflexes, workrate.

[Chase8400]

better speed, footwork, good chin, reflexes, workrate.

I know you are bull****ting now.

[hammerhiem]

better speed, footwork, good chin, reflexes, workrate.

Seriously a good chin vs a 175 is not the same as a good chin vs 240+

to put it in perspective that would be like hatton fighting Haye at CW.

[Underdog82]

lol sam peter would seriously hurt joe

lol no he wouldn't. He is a predictable fighter that calzaghe would figure out and run circles around. Easy UD for Calzaghe.

[mspiegelo]

no...................