After De La Hoya KO's Pacman, Calzaghe should be p4p no.1!

[Burner]

Really? Just curious but who would you rank above Calzaghe and who would be your p4p no.1 then?

If Pac loses.

1. JMM
2. Pacman
3. Hopkins
4. Calzage

[Pullcounter]

I dont think so. Pacquaio himself for instance, didnt 'earn' his topspot but got it when Mayweather retired.

yeah but since pac ain't retiring....

[Chups]

Wha? I thought JMM is on number 2? If Pac gets demolished then JMM becomes number 1.

[mrlopez]

I can't put calzaghe as the top p4p fighter...

in fact i dont even think he belongs as high as he is on the p4p list.

i mean other than career accomplishments who has he REALLY beat to earn the top p4p spot???

i mean he beat two old guys in roy jones jr and hopkins.

im sorry but i dont think he belongs as top p4p fighter...

Co-Sign.....

pac deserves P4P status because he got the balls to fight threats and real challengers!!

[BattlingNelson]

If Pac loses.

1. JMM
2. Pacman
3. Hopkins
4. Calzage

A slight error in your post as you got Hopkins over Calzaghe?

[Kris Silver]

Yes he should be. A lot were surprised he didn't move up one measley spot after beating Roy. It's not a majorly big win no, but Roy was still a top 10 ranked LHW by ring itself. So to not move at all seems odd.

I'm amazed by how most peoples excuses for him not being so high p4p are he fought bums in England, yet he beat mostly Americans usually top ranked in the division, in more countries then a lot of folk. The next one is a couple of old guys, well for one thing, factually regardless of anything, Hopkins was ranked what #4 P4P when Calzaghe beat him. You don't get there by chance. He was beating top guys, and went on to beat a top guy after wards too.

[BattlingNelson]

I am a bit surprised at the poll so far. I honestly thought Joe would be a clear no.1 in most peoples eyes. After all he did also move up to face Hopkins and RJJ and did it in their homecountry.

[paiid-in-full]

I have no problem giving Joe the pfp title if Del La Hoya wins impressively.

[paiid-in-full]

Or maybe Dawson.

[i box apples]

i say bump jmm to #1.

at least a nuthugger like me can still claim pac whooped a #1 p4p fighter even though pac is no longer #1.