Is Paulie Hatton's first LEGIT win?

[Naz Fan]

How did he become undisputed? He fought a sliding Mormeck, who'd averaged 1 fight a year for the previous 5 years, had been KO'd by Bell the year before, and who hasn't fought in the year since the Haye fight. Then fights the glass chinned Macaroni, who didn't have any notable wins on his resume. You seriously want to compare Haye's resume to Hatton's?

Face palm...

[warp1432]

Last time I looked Macronelli was still ranked top 10 at CW, thats AFTER he got beat by Haye.

beating a fellow top 10 at your weight is a legit win whatever you might think about a fighter.

Jean Marc Mormeck >>>> Enzo.

I wouldn't use Enzo into to proving he has that great of a resume. He's a good win, but Mormeck is much better.

[Jim Jeffries]

Hold on a sec, I aint talkin about hatton. Hattons resume is better than Haye's. I didnt say nothing about that.

He was number 1 cruiserweight nobody could beat him at that weight.

I would've had a lot more respect for Haye had he fought Cunningham, who was/is the strongest title holder at CW before running up to HW claiming that he cleaned out CW.

Anyway as for the thread, Hatton surprised me tonight. I thought he was shot after the Lazcano fight and even considered betting on Paulie, especially with the odds. Didn't think he'd had long enough to work with FMS to do any good, and possibly some harm.

[Steak]

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=224103

ok? who cares. Malignaggi is only so good, you cant overrate a win. Hatton has had a long, successful career. and I dont think the win over Malignaggi adds to it all that much.

The collazo win wasnt a clear cut win some people still think he lost that fight, People are also saying castillo was shot/gone, None could be said about Paulie M who was suppose to be the "boxer" type fighter.

Like i said before this is a great win for hatton and nobody should be able to play it down.

Its a solid win, but Ive never really been that impressed with Malignaggi. I think Hatton has had better wins in his career. although the Collazo fight was controversial, Collazo was a higher weight class champ and a pretty big Welterweight too...I think its a better win, especially considering that Hatton has trouble with southpaws sometimes.
Castillo was pretty shot, but the way Hatton took care of him and the winning streak Castillo was coming off of is more impressive than tonights victory to me. that left hook was painful.

[letsgobrady]

Err ranked 8 by ring mag... have won all 3 since and is the madatory for the IBF title.

Do you follow boxing or is it just Hatton hating that brings you here?

i know all that the point is that he's a nobody no one will ever favor him i over any of the more known jr ww, also remember that urango almost got knocked out in the fight after the hatton fight .

i'm not hatin on ricky i'm giving him his respect for beating one of the top better known jr ww in paulie

[Fox McCloud]

1. Tszyu
2. Collazo
3. Malignaggi
4. Castillo
5. Urango
6. Maussa

Thoughts?

[Sweet Pea 50]

1. Tszyu
2. Collazo
3. Malignaggi
4. Castillo
5. Urango
6. Maussa

Thoughts?

What is there to think about. Haye doesn't have a ****ing drop in a 10 gallon bucket when it comes down to the level of opposition Hatton has faced, and beaten.

[Fox McCloud]

What is there to think about. Haye doesn't have a ****ing drop in a 10 gallon bucket when it comes down to the level of opposition Hatton has faced, and beaten.

Real quick question...

What does your post mean?

[Sweet Pea 50]

Real quick question...

What does your post mean?

[Fox McCloud]