Is Paulie Hatton's first LEGIT win?

[Sweet Pea 50]

Still waiting for David Haye's first legit win.

[Pullcounter]

Apparently Tszyu was shot, so was Castillo, Collazo beat him, Urango is ****, Mayweather knocked him out and Lazcano almost knocked him out.

Is this the first real legit win Hatton haters wont be able to disprove?

nah... the tszyu win was legit.

[Steak]

This is a great win for Hatton..NO doubt, Paulie m is young..in his prime and ranked high at 140, No way would anyone be able to take this win away from Hatton, I think this is Hatton best win since his tsyzu victory.

bah, the Collazo and Castillo wins were better than this one. I hate to sound like a spoilsport, but Malignaggi isnt that great. he recently struggled against Ndou and Ngoudjo. sorry, but thats not very impressive.

not only that, but Malignaggi was almost the best opponent Hatton could have chose. he had no power whatsoever to keep Hatton off of him. stylestically, Juan Urango was a tougher opponent for him.

[squealpiggy]

bah, the Collazo and Castillo wins were better than this one. I hate to sound like a spoilsport, but Malignaggi isnt that great. he recently struggled against Ndou and Ngoudjo. sorry, but thats not very impressive.

not only that, but Malignaggi was almost the best opponent Hatton could have chose. he had no power whatsoever to keep Hatton off of him. stylestically, Juan Urango was a tougher opponent for him.

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=224103

[Jim Jeffries]

How can you be undisputed cruiserweight champ and not have any legit wins?

How did he become undisputed? He fought a sliding Mormeck, who'd averaged 1 fight a year for the previous 5 years, had been KO'd by Bell the year before, and who hasn't fought in the year since the Haye fight. Then fights the glass chinned Macaroni, who didn't have any notable wins on his resume. You seriously want to compare Haye's resume to Hatton's?

[letsgobrady]

He's beaten 3 out of the current ring mag top 10 at LWW.

Throw in 1 at WW plus Tszyu, Castillio and Stewart where all ranked top ten at the time of their fights with Hatton.

8 fights Vs top ten fighters won 7, not bad for a guy who "has not really done anything"

who did he beat urango who is he where is he know and was he highly touted and talked about? the rest of those people are a bunch of gate keepers castillo couldn't make weigh anymore thats a very bad sighn for a 35 year old fighter when you can't make the weight class that you have fought in for the majority of your career.
tszyu was the man so hatton gets all the respect for that win and paulie is a very slick boxer young he held the belt the was hattons and was considered to be the #1 jr ww and was thought to have the perfect style to beat hatton so much respect to hatton for that win

[Mersey]

How did he become undisputed? He fought a sliding Mormeck, who'd averaged 1 fight a year for the previous 5 years, had been KO'd by Bell the year before, and who hasn't fought in the year since the Haye fight. Then fights the glass chinned Macaroni, who didn't have any notable wins on his resume. You seriously want to compare Haye's resume to Hatton's?

Hold on a sec, I aint talkin about hatton. Hattons resume is better than Haye's. I didnt say nothing about that.

He was number 1 cruiserweight nobody could beat him at that weight.

[Ray*]

bah, the Collazo and Castillo wins were better than this one. I hate to sound like a spoilsport, but Malignaggi isnt that great. he recently struggled against Ndou and Ngoudjo. sorry, but thats not very impressive.

not only that, but Malignaggi was almost the best opponent Hatton could have chose. he had no power whatsoever to keep Hatton off of him. stylestically, Juan Urango was a tougher opponent for him.

The collazo win wasnt a clear cut win some people still think he lost that fight, People are also saying castillo was shot/gone, None could be said about Paulie M who was suppose to be the "boxer" type fighter.

Like i said before this is a great win for hatton and nobody should be able to play it down.

[Ray*]

How did he become undisputed? He fought a sliding Mormeck, who'd averaged 1 fight a year for the previous 5 years, had been KO'd by Bell the year before, and who hasn't fought in the year since the Haye fight. Then fights the glass chinned Macaroni, who didn't have any notable wins on his resume. You seriously want to compare Haye's resume to Hatton's?

Did you even read the threadstarter's thread??? He sint bashing hatton but hatton's haters that comes up with excuses for his wins.....read the thread again.

[hammerhiem]

who did he beat urango who is he where is he now

Err ranked 8 by ring mag... have won all 3 since and is the madatory for the IBF title.

Do you follow boxing or is it just Hatton hating that brings you here?