who agrees with me..mayweather
Collapse
-
-
When people talk about Pernell whitaker being more skilled than Mayweather, I politely disagree. Even just solely based on defense, I would still say Mayweather.
I know that sounds ridiculous, but the reason I say that is because Pea was great on defense no doubt, but I also lump in counterpunching with defense. I think Mayweather was a much, much better counterpuncher than Pea. Even though Pea was unhittable through most of his career and had the best upperbody movement in the world, he didn't punish fighters for their mistakes as well as Mayweather did.
Also, I think Mayweather has a much more solid grip on fundamental defense. Sure he might get more contact from punches than Pea did, but all of that contact is diffused with the way he blocked, used his gloves, shoulders, and forearms. Pernell's defense was more of the flashy, upper body and head movement variety. Bottom line is Mayweather's defense is just as effective in the end as Pea's if not more.Comment
-
Comment
-
He's definitely the best of this decade and of his generation but there were many skilled fighters out there in history, i dunno. I certainly can't see nothing wrong in anything i've ever seen him do in a ring but i never saw Robbinson fight live. I'd say he's Roy Jones good but with good fundamentals.Comment
-
I'll do my best to name them.
In the Top 5
Duran: Greatest defensive infighter...This natural 135 pounder went 15 rounds with Hagler and lost by 3 rounds. He K.O'd Iran Barkley...and the way he beat SRL 1st fight was jus amazin.
Mayweather: No need to explain you just ca't hit him clean, even if you had him against the ropes.
Prime James Toney altough, he wasn't very consistent...Like for example, he'd be that DAMN good and in his next fight he'd be good.
Pernell Whitaker: Needz no explaing
B-Hop: Still kickin azz at an old age and has GREAT defense. In his prime he was a BEAST a wicked brawler who STILL couldn't be hit even tough he wasn't as defensive as now.
Duran did not KO Barkley he won on points but he did have a huge 10th or 11th round where he nearly Ko'ed him he had him down and hurt badlyComment
-
I can only judge from the fighters I have seen footage of but out of those Mayweather is definately right up there if you are looking at pure skills. When I want to watch an incredible display of ability I usually either put on a Floyd or Pernell DVD.Comment
Comment