Who was best in his prime..Floyd, Roy, or Bernard?

[-MAKAVELLI-]

in his prime, NOONE beats Roy.....not joe, not nard, not toney, not anyone

[Wiley Hyena]

haha, your such a hater, his chin was'nt/is'nt that bad

Not a hater at all. The issue is who was the best of the remaining greats of the generation: Floyd, Roy, and Bernard.

[wmute]

Joe Calzaghe conquered Roy Jones, Jr. and Bernard Hopkins and as a result, sealed his place as the best of his generation. History has spoken. But, of the remaining contenders who was the best in his prime? I'll throw the Mayweather nuthuggers a bone and include lil' Floyd in the mix. Of Hopkins, Jones, and Mayweather, I've got to vote for Hopkins. Yes, Jones beat a young Hopkins, but I do believe the Hopkins of 1997-2000 would have beaten prime Jones. Hopkins was too crafty and would have been able to eventually get in and land on Jones' glass jaw. IMO Mayweather cannot be considered because he dodged the really big hitters, ie..Kostya Tszu, Antonio Margarito, and Miguel Cotto.

Trevor Berbick is the greatest

[wmute]

Joe would beat Bernard and Jones in their primes handily

Location: England

hmmm....

[Allucard]

Not a hater at all. The issue is who was the best of the remaining greats of the generation: Floyd, Roy, and Bernard.

Listen here biatch, JC is a fake white boy like Marciano was. That is the truth. He is and always will be a good fghter but not even he deserves a mention as a great.

[Chr0nic]

Listen here biatch, JC is a fake white boy like Marciano was. That is the truth. He is and always will be a good fghter but not even he deserves a mention as a great.

gone a bit far there but ooook....


*leaves thread*

[wmute]

I'd say Jones or Mayweather.

Hopkins physical peak doesnt coincide with his game's peak.

Mayweather also spent what could have been his best years (26-28) at his best weights (35-40) quite inactive, fighting bums and going to court, so as spectacular as he was, he spent his peak fighting the worse stretch of opposition of his career.

[wmute]

Listen here biatch, JC is a fake white boy like Marciano was. That is the truth. He is and always will be a good fghter but not even he deserves a mention as a great.

umm... ehm.... are you mad at someone?

[MANGLER]

Prime RJ was the man.

[Wiley Hyena]

Listen here biatch, JC is a fake white boy like Marciano was. That is the truth. He is and always will be a good fghter but not even he deserves a mention as a great.

So who did you vote for? I know you would never vote for a "fake white boy" so why include Calzaghe in the list? Evidently, the poll clearly shows that most think RJJ was the best in his prime....surprisingly.