EX Hopkins v Lightsout Toney prime 4 prime catch weight

[Dynamite Kid]

I got Toney by UD or Late TKO, he hits harder, is a busier tactician and has more savvy


It would be one hell of a press conference though!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

LOL@Toney knocking Hopkins out

there is NO fighter active today that is more ring savvy than Hopkins

that post was

[MELLY-MEL...]

2 of my atg fav's!!!! hard to say man. i gotta ride the fence on this one T. can't for the life of me call it!

[freedom213]

EX Hopkins v Lights out Toney prime 4 prime catch weight

i got EX i think he would make Toney come to him and he would get in and out and land some clean effective shots and pot shot his way to a decision i dont wanna disrespect a GREAT fighter like Toney but i think EX is too smart for him and once he worked out how to get through his D i think he would win

Hopkins was and is a tape freak he would dissect Toney's style

funniest thread I have seen, James Toney at a catch weight, GTF outta here dude! Only weight Toney catches is the half piece a chicken leg that falls out of his mouth while he's in-between chews. And by the way I like Toney, he just has what we call a "weight problem".

[TheGreatA]

funniest thread I have seen, James Toney at a catch weight, GTF outta here dude! Only weight Toney catches is the half piece a chicken leg that falls out of his mouth while he's in-between chews. And by the way I like Toney, he just has what we call a "weight problem".

Prime for prime.

There would be no real need for a catchweight since both fought at 160 and 168.

160 would favour Hopkins and 168 would favour Toney though, so it could be fought at a catchweight.

[MikeBrew328]

I got Hopkins. Toney is too inconsistent. Hopkins UD

[oldgringo]

Prime for prime.

There would be no real need for a catchweight since both fought at 160 and 168.

160 would favour Hopkins and 168 would favour Toney though, so it could be fought at a catchweight.

I agree.

If both men are at their absolute best (generally how you judge fantasy matchups) then I'd take JT. All of this inconsistent **** doesn't matter when you are considering both men would be fit and ready to fight.

[Silencers]

It's a bad stylistic matchup for both of them, I can't see either one of them winning clearly, close decision that could go either way.

[AntonTheMeh]

i pick toney.............

[El Dominicano]

EX Hopkins v Lights out Toney prime 4 prime catch weight

i got EX i think he would make Toney come to him and he would get in and out and land some clean effective shots and pot shot his way to a decision i dont wanna disrespect a GREAT fighter like Toney but i think EX is too smart for him and once he worked out how to get through his D i think he would win

Hopkins was and is a tape freak he would dissect Toney's style

If we're talking about a healthy James Toney, I'll admitt...This fight can go either way.

[Tmb04]

B-Hop would do the same thing to Toney as Jones did.