Who has a better resume? Manny Pacquiao or Joe Calzaghe?

[Clegg]

Pacquiao. I voted Calzaghe by mistake, sorry

[BlackHat]

pacquiao. I Voted Calzaghe By Mistake, Sorry

Lol!!!!!!!!!!!! just so they know.

[tito yuca]

Pacquiao has many losses on his record. IMO he lost twice against Marquez, and he lost against Morales in their first fight. He was also knocked out twice earlier in his career. When has anything like this happened to Calzaghe? This is not even close. Calzaghe dominated a division for a decade then went up in weight and beat two legends, who while past their best, many predicted would defeat him.

[We want Floyd]

I don't know. I do know this though : I made a poll last night about who between Calzaghe and Pacquiao was the ultimate Senior Citizen slayer, and it went neck in neck.

I didn't know 29 years old was the new 43 years old. Please kid, When PAC ****ted on MAB, MAB was a top 5 P4P fighter at 29 yrs of age. When PAC faced Erika, Erika's only losses was against another great fighter, MAB. Erika lost to Raheem due to two things, size and speed. What makes ya think Erika would not have lost to Raheem at any other point in his career, speed has always been Erika's kryptonite!

Juan Manuel Marquez was also a top 10 P4P fighter going into his rematch against PAC. Jones, Jr and B-Hop weren't even listed in the top 10 P4P rankings when they faced Calzaghe.

PAC has faced a total of 4(including Larios) proven veteran world champions, Calzaghe simply faced two fighters who were simply names that looked great on paper and two other fighters who had more hype than substance ie Lacy and Kessler.

[Hous]

Pacquiao and its not even close.

Pacquiao has a resume that dreams are made of. Long stand back to back to back to back to back... superfights with both men being in undisputed primes.

[Flawless 2]

Pacquiao has many losses on his record. IMO he lost twice against Marquez, and he lost against Morales in their first fight. He was also knocked out twice earlier in his career. When has anything like this happened to Calzaghe? This is not even close. Calzaghe dominated a division for a decade then went up in weight and beat two legends, who while past their best, many predicted would defeat him.

You know Calzaghe was favourite over Hopkins and RJJ

[Hous]

I didn't know 29 years old was the new 43 years old. Please kid, When PAC ****ted on MAB, MAB was a top 5 P4P fighter at 29 yrs of age. When PAC faced Erika, Erika's only losses was against another great fighter, MAB. Erika lost to Raheem due to two things, size and speed. What makes ya think Erika would not have lost to Raheem at any other point in his career, speed has always been Erika's kryptonite!

Juan Manuel Marquez was also a top 10 P4P fighter going into his rematch against PAC. Jones, Jr and B-Hop weren't even listed in the top 10 P4P rankings when they faced Calzaghe.

PAC has faced a total of 4(including Larios) proven veteran world champions, Calzaghe simply faced two fighters who were simply names that looked great on paper and two other fighters who had more hype than substance ie Lacy and Kessler.

Kessler is not hype, he will make the P4P list soon.

IDK hes being overlooked. Europeans have a way of hyping mediocore fighters, but Kessler is a great fighter and his hype is gone.

[Flawless 2]

Kessler is not hype, he will make the P4P list soon.

After beating who?? His best win is still Mundine

[Pullcounter]

Manny Pacquiao is recognized as the p4p number 1 fighter in the world. Joe Calzaghe is recognized as the 2nd.

Who do you all think has the better overall resume?

Manny Pacquiao's four biggest wins
Juan Manuel Marquez SD 12
Marco Antonio Barrera UD 12 and TKO 11
Erik Morales KO 3 and TKO 10
Oscar Larios UD 12

Joe Calzaghe's four biggest wins
Roy Jones Jr UD 12
Bernard Hopkins SD 12
Mikkel Kessler UD 12
Jeff Lacy UD 12

Pacquiao's resume is definitely stronger.

RJJ was shot. Hopkins 43 years old gave calzaghe his toughest fight.

Pacquiao buzzsawed his way through his contemporaries. JMM lost 2x to Pac and JMM is in his prime.

[BlackHat]

Pacquiao has many losses on his record. IMO he lost twice against Marquez, and he lost against Morales in their first fight. He was also knocked out twice earlier in his career. When has anything like this happened to Calzaghe? This is not even close. Calzaghe dominated a division for a decade then went up in weight and beat two legends, who while past their best, many predicted would defeat him.

LOL! talking about beating the odds. JC was the favorite against Bhop and RJJ, Pacquiao was the under dog against MAB and Morales.