Donaire Breaks Finger, Darchinyan Rematch Unlikely

[loui_ludwig]

exactly two of the three judges had the fight even. Now I will say my scorecard had a slight edge to Donaire but he wasn't "totally dominating"

Yes, the 2 judges have it even and 1 have it for Nonito, 3 rounds to 1. Even the commentator have it the same as 1 judge.

You said you have a slight edge for Donaire. How many rounds did you give Donaire up to the 4th rounds?

[KingArthur]

Yes, the 2 judges have it even and 1 have it for Nonito, 3 rounds to 1. Even the commentator have it the same as 1 judge.

You said you have a slight edge for Donaire. How many rounds did you give Donaire up to the 4th rounds?

I had it 3 to 1 as well and thats as slight as it get when your fighting 12 rds. But people are making sound like it was 4 SHUT-OUT rds for Donaire. NO! I t wasn't

[-Antonio-]

I think they are overrating Donaire a bit. He just got a good punch in, that Vic couldnt recover from, just like Rahman caught lewis. If the rematch happends, Vic will destroy donaire, Vic have lots of power, and now with decent defense and good boxing, thats mortal. Vic KO 8 Donaire!!

I keep reading this now, and I dont get it. Donaire was winning comfortably and tagging Vic all night. There was no lucky punch. In fact it was a beautifully timed counter on top of that.

[loui_ludwig]

I had it 3 to 1 as well and thats as slight as it get when your fighting 12 rds. But people are making sound like it was 4 SHUT-OUT rds for Donaire. NO! I t wasn't

I scored it the same. It wasn't a shut out but it was 3 rounds to 1. And if the 5th round was scored up to the KO, i have it for Donaire.

[Mr. Ryan]

You do realize that nonito is moving up to super fly where vic is the #1 man with three belts. Even if nonito cleans out the divison, he will not be conisderd number one unless he beats vic in a rematch or vic moves up and vacates the titles. Vics resume will never be questioned he koed Irene Pacheco, one of the best flywieghts, in his own backyard. He succefully defended his title numerous times. he moved up to superfly beat z gorres (dont bull**** yourself that it was a draw anybody with half an eye could tell you it wasent), kod dimitri kirlov (had never been kod before) to become a 2 time champ. Beat the #1 guy in mijares by dominant ko and outboxing him (never been kod before), and becamme the first man to unify three titles in the superflywieght divison. Nonito has won the ibf title and defended it against vics leftovers and a no namer. So you keep telling yourself that vics resume will always be questioned. lol.

Couldn't the same be said that until Darchinyan avenges his defeat, his belts will be hollow?

Vic's leftovers, yes Maldonado was that, but Mthalane was a number one contender. If you don't fight those guys, you lose your belt.

[Espada]

You do realize that nonito is moving up to super fly where vic is the #1 man with three belts. Even if nonito cleans out the divison, he will not be conisderd number one unless he beats vic in a rematch or vic moves up and vacates the titles. Vics resume will never be questioned he koed Irene Pacheco, one of the best flywieghts, in his own backyard. He succefully defended his title numerous times. he moved up to superfly beat z gorres (dont bull**** yourself that it was a draw anybody with half an eye could tell you it wasent), kod dimitri kirlov (had never been kod before) to become a 2 time champ. Beat the #1 guy in mijares by dominant ko and outboxing him (never been kod before), and becamme the first man to unify three titles in the superflywieght divison. Nonito has won the ibf title and defended it against vics leftovers and a no namer. So you keep telling yourself that vics resume will always be questioned. lol.

Are you an idiot? Who cares if Vic is the 3 belt holder? If Nonito moves up, everyone knows Donaire knock his ass out.. No one will forget that.
Darchinyan still got knock the F U C K out. Although there's no need for a rematch because he was outboxed clearly, commentators and every media analyst wants a Donaire rematch.. Nonito doesn't need to prove anything, whether he has 1 belt at 115 or not.. Everyone knows whose better who did the chicken dance and got knock the F U C K out.

[ragingvic]

Are you an idiot? Who cares if Vic is the 3 belt holder? If Nonito moves up, everyone knows Donaire knock his ass out.. No one will forget that.
Darchinyan still got knock the F U C K out. Although there's no need for a rematch because he was outboxed clearly, commentators and every media analyst wants a Donaire rematch.. Nonito doesn't need to prove anything, whether he has 1 belt at 115 or not.. Everyone knows whose better who did the chicken dance and got knock the F U C K out.

No you are the idiot for thinking one loss ruins a otherwise great resume and that one win makes a legacy.

[Mr. Ryan]

No you are the idiot for thinking one loss ruins a otherwise great resume and that one win makes a legacy.

I'm still in favor of avenging the only loss a fighter has, especially if that fighters stock is still high and is a notable figure in the division.

[ragingvic]

Couldn't the same be said that until Darchinyan avenges his defeat, his belts will be hollow?

Vic's leftovers, yes Maldonado was that, but Mthalane was a number one contender. If you don't fight those guys, you lose your belt.

Why would his belts be hollow? he beat the man, twice (kirilov and mijares). Its a new division, one where vic is the #1 guy. To be number one you got to beat the number one, not two years back but now. Ricardo Espinoza beat mijares, yet mijares was still the number one dude and a p4per without avengenig his defeat.

[ragingvic]

I'm still in favor of avenging the only loss a fighter has, especially if that fighters stock is still high and is a notable figure in the division.

Def i would love for the rematch to happen, but i woulndt say vic needs it more then nonito. Vic is doing just fine without the rematch.