Who's win over Hopkins was more impressive...

[S.G.]

the question is unclear.

Jones won more clearly but the question was, who beat the better version?

Two questions in one.

i meant, taking both things into consideration (the nature of the victory and where Hopkins was at at that point), which do you feel was the more impressive victory...i might not have phrased myself well

[deemo]

i still think prime for prime roy could beat hopkins and joe or anybody fighting today for that matter.

[Pullcounter]

Calzaghe's split decision in '08 or Jones Jr.'s unanimous decision in '93

Which version of Hopkins was tougher, and closer to his best?
...the young (okay, not that young), green, not fully developed version Roy Jones beat, or the (very) old version Calzaghe sc****d a win over?

Does the nature of the wins reflect their skill set or Hopkins'?

Vote and discuss.

jones beat hopkins decisively like 8-4. calzaghe barely eeked out a win.