Wladimir Klitschko vs. James Toney: who would win?

[Porter's Dad]

I wouldn't like to see this fight, simply because I wouldn't like to see someone like Wlad knockout JT, which he probably would. This version of Toney, anyway.

JT is so much more skillful and aesthetically pleasing, but Wlad's size and power.....too much for a 41 year old Toney.

[Stickman]

Toney would have to stand on a GODDAMNED STEPLADDER just to reach Wlad's chin. Tunney, is this a joke thread?

[Randall_Hopkirk]

Toney would be jabbed into submission and eventually stopped on his feet. Or his corner would throw in the towel.

[Pugilistic™]

Klitschko wins.

[The Hammer]

Toney would have to stand on a GODDAMNED STEPLADDER just to reach Wlad's chin. Tunney, is this a joke thread?

Wlad is about the same height as Lennox Lewis, he says he's just under 6'6", and Toney is 5'10", the same height as Mike Tyson and David Tua.

Lennox (reach = 84") had a greater reach advantage over Tyson (reach = 71", 13" advantage for Lewis) and Tua (reach = 70", 14" advantage for Lewis) than Wladimir (reach = 81") has over Toney (reach = 72", 9" advantage for Wlad).

[TheGreatA]

Wlad is about the same height as Lennox Lewis, he says he's just under 6'6", and Toney is 5'10", the same height as Mike Tyson and David Tua.

Lennox (reach = 84") had a greater reach advantage over Tyson (reach = 71", 13" advantage for Lewis) and Tua (reach = 70", 14" advantage for Lewis) than Wladimir (reach = 81") has over Toney (reach = 72", 9" advantage for Wlad).

Mike Tyson


David Tua


James Toney


Toney in his prime

[The Hammer]

James "Belly's Out" Toney would be able to afford a liposuction after receiving a good payday getting KOed by Wlad.

[boxingfan405]

like i said toney is short fat slub that will be outboxed much taller and stronger wlad. peace

[KESSLER]

I think Wladimir knocks him out. He is too big, too powerful for Toney who is well past his prime . He's still got his chin, and he will need it, I think he will end up eating alot of big rights hands before getting knocked out.

[KESSLER]

Toney in his prime

Toney in his prime was a bad dude.