If Mayweather Does this...is he the greatest boxer of all time?

[BLOODGOD]

I don't wanna get in another war with you over this **** but how is a man who was outboxed in both fights against a very good boxer in JMM supposed to beat a guy who is bigger than Marquez and does everything that he does but better.

Floyd would give Pac a whooping.

So you prefer marquez got a chance of beating mayweather than pacman?

[them_apples]

I don't understand how some people can write off a fighter like Pacquiao so easily, he's p4p no.1 right now..he's only got better.

Every fighter has trouble with someone at some point, but they learn from it.

Mayweather had trouble with Castillo, does that mean he sucks? Castillo isn't a huge guy.

Pacquiao could give Mayweather a very good fight, he's very fast on his feet, he throws a lot..lets just see how he does against DLH and maybe a more accurate opinion can be made.

[tferguson]

No because these fighters aren't as good as fighters of past ages, and second the best fighter has a ko punch, a solid chin and can box or fight. Do you think either Margarito or Cotto could even be considered in the top 100 welterweights? No any boxing historian will tell you that.

[Dan...]

I don't understand how some people can write off a fighter like Pacquiao so easily, he's p4p no.1 right now..he's only got better.

Every fighter has trouble with someone at some point, but they learn from it.

Mayweather had trouble with Castillo, does that mean he sucks? Castillo isn't a huge guy.

Pacquiao could give Mayweather a very good fight, he's very fast on his feet, he throws a lot..lets just see how he does against DLH and maybe a more accurate opinion can be made.

I'm writing Pac off because I do not see a feasible way for him to win that fight. There is no way he can stop Floyd and there is no way he can win a decision over him. Thus, he loses.

He is just too easy to hit. Floyd would be nailing him with straight right leads all night. Manny just wouldn't be able to get going.

[Vasyl’s dad]

Comes back beats

Cotto
Margarito
P.Williams
De La Hoya Again


If not what else does he have to de?

Hi, I see you're new to this wonderful, one on one sport we all love and call boxing.


Hope you stick around to learn more about the sport.

[Golden Boy 360]

Hi, I see you're new to this wonderful, one on one sport we all love and call boxing.



Hope you stick around to learn more about the sport.

trust me i will

[The_Italian]

Comes back beats

Cotto
Margarito
P.Williams
De La Hoya Again


If not what else does he have to de?

for me i'd be happy if he fought pacquiao, cotto, and rematched de la hoya...but even then i wouldnt call him the greatest of all time...he'd be an all time great...but not THEE GREATEST...

margarito would be an important fight for him but im not including it on my list because i feel that floyd would have a harder time with a miguel cotto than an antonio margarito...

cotto is more technically sound and could actually BOX floyd...

Margarito isn't as polished and his best assests are his workrate and chin...then again look what happened with hatton??? floyd would never knock margarito out but he'd smother him and tie him up whenever possible; not allowing margarito to get off his punches...not give margarito the distance he needs to have the most effect with his punches...

he would basically something along the lines of what he did with hatton and what hopkins did with pavlik...

only exciting detail of that matchup would be no matter the score (even if margarito losses every round going into the 12th) he still has a punchers chance to stop floyd and win the fight at any time...beyond that he cant outbox floyd...he cant out think floyd...he has to attempt to go in there and **** with him and floyd wouldnt allow that.

williams i dont view as a big threat to floyd either...

i say de la hoya due to how close their first fight was (i had it even)...and how much cotto's boxing ability has come along...and pacquaio's speed/power...those would probably be the best 3 fights he can make in my opinion.

[Easy-E]

maybe if he beat williams and marg that would put him up there, a cotto fight is pointless unless he avenges against Margarito.
Also if he fought Pac (assuming he beats oscar) than that would also put him up there

[ReadyUp]

he has to fight Hopkins, or Jones then he must fight ME and show love and support for the butcher of Baghdad, Saddam Hussein R.I.P [IMG]http://i516.***********.com/albums/u327/Ldjb89/PresidentSaddamHussein.jpg[/IMG]

hahahahahah.

[crold1]

It would probably make him one of the Greatest but there really isn't, not even Rob, a single fighter who cam't have a case made against them for the top spot even with strong cases for.