Let's all agree now. Calzaghe is an ATG.

[daggum]

It was a win. Not nearly as controversial as DLH's win over Sturm.

lol it was not a win. imagine if you weren't biased? that would be a revelation. at least de la hoya put up a fight he didnt get frustrated and start swinging his arms nonstop like a clown.

[Flawless 2]

Im not in any way a Calzaghe fan but you really need to get real Joe won. Press row was 75-25 in Calzaghes favour.

Associated Press, Yahoo, and ESPN scored the bout 114-113 for Hopkins

[daggum]

Im not in any way a Calzaghe fan but you really need to get real Joe won. Press row was 75-25 in Calzaghes favour.

another lie almost everyone on press row had hopkins winning.

[boxasmash]

lets be honest.. anyone who thinks otherwise is a complete idiot

[Greatwhitehope]

Jermaine Taylor beat him twice, therefore Jermaine is king of the all time greats.

[BattlingNelson]

lol it was not a win. imagine if you weren't biased? that would be a revelation. at least de la hoya put up a fight he didnt get frustrated and start swinging his arms nonstop like a clown.

It was a close fight that's for sure. Calzaghe got the nod. Accept the fact and stop whining.

Don't call me biased towards Calzaghe. I hate his slaps as much as anybody. But noone has solved his style. He has passed every test. Therefore he is an ATG.

[Flawless 2]

It was a close fight that's for sure. Calzaghe got the nod. Accept the fact and stop whining.

Don't call me biased towards Calzaghe. I hate his slaps as much as anybody. But noone has solved his style. He has passed every test. Therefore he is an ATG.

Every test??

Kessler (unproven)
Hopkins 43 years old and he has a case he won the fight
Than that leaves us Eubank

[BattlingNelson]

Every test??

Kessler (unproven)
Hopkins 43 years old and he has a case he won the fight
Than that leaves us Eubank

Who has he got left? Vitali?

[boxasmash]

just because oscar beat floyd, i thought you was leaving anyway flawless?

[Flawless 2]

Who has he got left? Vitali?

You really call those fights a test?? Aren't you the one who claims Kessler hand was hurt before the Calzaghe bout and did not sparr