Calzaghe GREAT!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Chuckguy]

What to you makes a fighter great? Is it record, where they fought, opposition, PPV draw what? I just got into a discussion about Joe C and being great. I think he is good not great one was a dueche and the other I have respect for him and his knowledge. So leading back to my question what makes a fighter great.
IMO great is RJJ, Mayweather, Ali, SRR, Ray Leonard, Vargas (haha just playin) JCC, Mosely at 135 just to name a very few oh yeah Ric I cant leve out prime Tyson
talk it up fellas
who is great and is Joe C a great?????

[them_apples]

What to you makes a fighter great? Is it record, where they fought, opposition, PPV draw what? I just got into a discussion about Joe C and being great. I think he is good not great one was a dueche and the other I have respect for him and his knowledge. So leading back to my question what makes a fighter great.
IMO great is RJJ, Mayweather, Ali, SRR, Ray Leonard, Vargas (haha just playin) JCC, Mosely at 135 just to name a very few oh yeah Ric I cant leve out prime Tyson
talk it up fellas
who is great and is Joe C a great?????

He's good..I can't help but feel he's on the verge of losing and that he's carefully picking fights, I never felt like he was trying to get the best match ever for greatness.

[Chuckguy]

He's good..I can't help but feel he's on the verge of losing and that he's carefully picking fights, I never felt like he was trying to get the best match ever for greatness.

That is my point exactly. He is good to be 45-0 you have to be good but he hasnt really taken any risks in his career. He fought Kessler and I give him all the props but thats it
he thinks he is great for fighting Kessler and an old hopkins???

[j.razor]

Roy Jones Jr., Floyd Maywearther Jr., Bernard Hopkins, James Toney= GREAT. joe is just your average joe...

[larryx]

calzaghe is far from great..hes barely above average

[Shanus]

Calzaghe is ****.

[extracurRICular]

What to you makes a fighter great? Is it record, where they fought, opposition, PPV draw what? I just got into a discussion about Joe C and being great. I think he is good not great one was a dueche and the other I have respect for him and his knowledge. So leading back to my question what makes a fighter great.
IMO great is RJJ, Mayweather, Ali, SRR, Ray Leonard, Vargas (haha just playin) JCC, Mosely at 135 just to name a very few oh yeah Ric I cant leve out prime Tyson
talk it up fellas
who is great and is Joe C a great?????

Hell yeah prime Iron Mike Tyson is legit!!! I say what makes him great was skill, knowledge of the game and above all his well earned rep...fools were beat before they even entered the ring when they had to face IMT...not very often you get a kat that was so feared as IMT...I can't even think of any other boxer today who was that aura about him...I'd have to go back to Foreman days for that....