Hall Of Famers? Yay or Nay?

[S.W.F.C]

Agree with what everyone has said, yes for all apart from Marg at this moment in time.

[boxaholic]

mike tyson
lennox lewis
roy jones junior
joe calzaghe
bernard hopkins
de la hoya
antonio margarito
floyd mayweather

discuss

All of them except Margarito. Any of those fighters have beaten multiple world calss fighters except for Margarito. He has only beat 1.

[S.G.]

all of em except Margarito

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

mike tyson
lennox lewis
roy jones junior
joe calzaghe
bernard hopkins
de la hoya
antonio margarito
floyd mayweather

discuss

Lewis - Yes
Jones - Lock
Calz - no
Hop - Lock
DLH - lock
Margarito - no
Mayweather - lock

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

All of 'em.

That is just ******.

[kenso]

mike tyson - debatable, i say no since he had such a terrible ending to his career
lennox lewis - no
roy jones junior - **** no
joe calzaghe - no, and if he beats jones then pavlik MAAAAAAAAYBE
bernard hopkins - yes
de la hoya - if he beats pac and marg, yes
antonio margarito - not yet
floyd mayweather - not yet

[Scott9945]

All of them are sure HOFers apart from Margarito.

Absolutely. And Margarito still has the chance to make his case.

[Silencers]

Absolutely. And Margarito still has the chance to make his case.

Definitely, Margarito has quite some time to make an impact at 147 and then possibly at 154 to earn his way into the HOF.

[DIOS DOMINICANO]

Absolutely. And Margarito still has the chance to make his case.

Scott,

We were in a similar discussion last week.

Please go back and see the guys who are in. the standard is WAAAY higher than you are setting. Very few of the current guys from the middle divisions are getting in.

Very few.

...in NO WAY is Calzaghe a lock. Undefeated record and all. The Hall has GENERALLY not put it guys who are "best of the past couple of years at his class" (TTN, notwithstanding). The IBHOF has been rewarding transcendant fighters. Guys like Roy or Floyd.

[harper8081]

your an idiot.