Is Tarver a Hall of Famer?

[ИATAS]

With wins over:
Roy Jones (TWICE)
Glen Johnson (also lost)
Montell Griffin
Clinton Woods

Losses over:
Hopkins (badly)
Johnson (split decision)
Eric Harding (who he beat in rematch)

I think he's a big MAYBE. But if he beats Chad Dawson, I think he has a pretty good shot.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

as a tarver hater, i hope not

[TijuanaTornado!]

He also beat rocky balboa

balboa > all the others you named

However, he is NOT a HOF. For the simple reason he owns a 50 cent album

[mrlopez]

Dont like Tarver, but think if he beats Dawson and maybe unifies with a fight agaisnt the other belt holders and wins, he's in

[QuCongee]

Balboa was a bum with 27 losses.

[chosen1]

Balboa was a bum with 27 losses.

good stuff...lol

[Dynamite Kid]

yes and he does not get the props he deserves

[TijuanaTornado!]

Balboa > Mr T. Mr T > loads of bad guys with gunz

[TheManchine]

With wins over:
Roy Jones (TWICE)
Glen Johnson (also lost)
Montell Griffin
Clinton Woods

Losses over:
Hopkins (badly)
Johnson (split decision)
Eric Harding (who he beat in rematch)

I think he's a big MAYBE. But if he beats Chad Dawson, I think he has a pretty good shot.

possibly,

the first Johnson fight i thought he won,

if he beats Dawson i think he could possibly get in,

meh i dont know

[KnockoutTheFat]

Let's ask TheMagicMan