this generation ATGs

[boxasmash]

joe calzaghe

[tredh]

I'm definately not making the case for him to be in right now but as of right now those he beat ARE the whos who of the division and a good foundation for him getting into the hall of fame.

Also, even tho he won by the skin of his teeth, Margarito beat, Golden Johnson, GOLDEN ****IN 24 KARAT JOHNSON, can Ray Leonard do that?

Ok he beat Cotto can't take that away from very good win like I said earlier that is his only high profile notable win. Margarito's win over Clottey some view as controversial because of how the fight was going before Clottey injured himself. Some will say well Margarito was injured also but the fact remains everybody's body react differently to their own injuries. He lost to Williams. So this 1 very good win, a controversial win, and a loss. That is a very shaky foundation IMO but I get what you are saying.

LMAO at the bold

[Dice]

Ok he beat Cotto can't take that away from very good win like I said earlier that is his only high profile notable win. Margarito's win over Clottey some view as controversial because of how the fight was going before Clottey injured himself. Some will say well Margarito was injured also but the fact remains everybody's body react differently to their own injuries. He lost to Williams. So this 1 very good win, a controversial win, and a lost. That is a very shaky foundation IMO but I get what you are saying.

LMAO at the bold

And I see where ur gettin at too, good debate, but you cant deny that Golden Johnson is a Limousine Ridin', Jet Flying, Kiss Stealin', Wheelin' Dealin', Son of a Gun

[larryx]

floyd-top 20 atg
roy-top 15 atg maybe top 10
hopkins-top 25-30 atg top 5 middleweight ever
toney-top 50-75 atg
pacman-top-100 atg

[Chuckguy]

Paul Williams for cleaning out 147 154 and winning titles in 160 168 and 175

Man if you are gonna put Slim in there then I have to say Berto
LMAO

[Dice]

Man I'm impressed so much by Floyds resume that I forget to look at Roy's resume and fail to relize he's even better then Floyd, losses or not Roy was damn near super human, and really made it look easy