this generation ATGs

[gazzboy561]

does anyone think that there are any fighters who are be rank on the ATG list and does anyone think theres a fighter you can crack the top 10 ATG list ? please explain

[GreatestIam]

Floyd is defintely a ATG, i think Cotto will go down as a bad mother****er very Duran like, so will Kelly Pavlik, **** i think KP has the most upside this generation to be 1 of the best MW ever!

[Dice]

I think Floyd is an ATG, I gotta see more from Kelly, and while not p4p atg, I think Jose Luis Castillo is an ATG at lightweight, and Pac Man and Marquez as well

[THE REED]

roy son.... roy

[Flawless 2]

Paul Williams for cleaning out 147 154 and winning titles in 160 168 and 175

[GreatestIam]

Roy dont count, Hopkins or Toney.. The fact is you dont see noone sayin Joe C , cuz he aint no ATG just a great champ... thats the difference between guys like, JLC and Shane Mosely, JLC was a great champ Mosely is a ATG IMO| Pac-Man is a toss up so are alot of guys..

[Flawless 2]

Pacman
Mayweather

[Dice]

Roy dont count, Hopkins or Toney.. The fact is you dont see noone sayin Joe C , cuz he aint no ATG just a great champ... thats the difference between guys like, JLC and Shane Mosely, JLC was a great champ Mosely is a ATG IMO| Pac-Man is a toss up so are alot of guys..

Why Roy dont count? or Hopkins?

And yea u got it pretty right with the JLC Mosley comparision although I think Castillo could have beaten Mosley with the way he fought against Mayweather, Mosley was a machine at lightweight tho

[toluco]

margarito is a guaranteed hall of famer
if he can beat cotto again and mosley and win a title at 154 and 160 i think he can be an all time great

[GreatestIam]

Roy, Hop and Toney been around since the early 90s and why debate there status we know there HOFers... its guys like Floyd, ODLH, Mosely who are proven but still where like, hmm damn he lost that fight, or he shoulda fought him, him and him... IMO