P4P: De La Hoya or Lennox Lewis?

[Ryn0]

I have to go with LEnnox with this one...but after Dec 6th oscar will surpass him with his devastating KO.

No chance, a win over Pacquiao does Jack all for his legacy.

[Domain]

No chance, a win over Pacquiao does Jack all for his legacy.

always trying to discredit Oscar's achievements! such a shame.

Oscar has fought nothing but the best! and again he fights the p4p king give him his due when he wins! he will be p4p number 1 after he knocks out pacman.

[Fox McCloud]

always trying to discredit Oscar's achievements! such a shame.

Oscar has fought nothing but the best! and again he fights the p4p king give him his due when he wins! he will be p4p number 1 after he knocks out pacman.

Does Klitschko beating Mijares do anything for his legacy? Does it make him jump into the P4P rankings?

If not, please reconsider how much credit you are giving to De La Hoya for beating a man who is way, way, way smaller than him.

[Domain]

Does Klitschko beating Mijares do anything for his legacy? Does it make him jump into the P4P rankings?

If not, please reconsider how much credit you are giving to De La Hoya for beating a man who is way, way, way smaller than him.

stop exaggerating! thats too far of a weight difference you are just being silly.
Oscar will prove you guys wrong! he will finish pacman in a devastating fashion and everyone one of you will have to hang your head in ashame! I will be here will you when oscar wins

[Ryn0]

always trying to discredit Oscar's achievements! such a shame.

Oscar has fought nothing but the best! and again he fights the p4p king give him his due when he wins! he will be p4p number 1 after he knocks out pacman.

If Pavlik beat Margarito would he get any credit? NO! you're a moron.

You're the only person here that thinks De la Hoya will jump up any rankings once he beat Pacquiao. He fought the best and lost most to most of them (he shouold have beat Trinidad) Oscar doesn't come close to the top 10 P4P with a win over Manny

[Easy-E]

De La Hoya.
He fought the best of his era and beat many of them.
De La faced far better opposition, moved up and down in weight and was still a premire fighter. He also was involved in the most compeitive divisions. The same cannot be said for Lennox.

[Ryn0]

stop exaggerating! thats too far of a weight difference you are just being silly.
Oscar will prove you guys wrong! he will finish pacman in a devastating fashion and everyone one of you will have to hang your head in ashame! I will be here will you when oscar wins

ARE YOU NOT READING RIGHT? ****ING moron everyone expects Oscar to win. He has a ****** size advatange. He will get no credit from anyone apart from YOU.

[Easy-E]

Does Klitschko beating Mijares do anything for his legacy? Does it make him jump into the P4P rankings?

If not, please reconsider how much credit you are giving to De La Hoya for beating a man who is way, way, way smaller than him.

They are fighting at the same weight class.
FMJ fights and beats up light heavys in the gym, and fights at his walking around weight, meaning many of his competitors, even Hatton, are considered "bigger" than him.
Its all relative, but I would not discredit Oscar for beating Pacquiao, because Manny is a great fighter.

[Domain]

If Pavlik beat Margarito would he get any credit? NO! you're a moron.

You're the only person here that thinks De la Hoya will jump up any rankings once he beat Pacquiao. He fought the best and lost most to most of them (he shouold have beat Trinidad) Oscar doesn't come close to the top 10 P4P with a win over Manny

Does hagler deserve credit for beating tommy hearns? your logic is flaw man

ryno my friend if Pavlik Beats Margarito he will get BIG CREDIT! but he would expose that bully as a bum! Marg if he had half the balls would go up to a natural weight like 154 and 160 and challenge the best insted of crying the small 147 pound guys are avoidig him. Margo likes small guys he avoids the big guys he only fought P wil because he thought he was an easy mandatory.

also by you saying oscar doesnt raise in the rankings with a win over pacman shows your lack of respect for pacman! basically you saying pacman is a bum...but the truth is pacman is p4p number 1 so oscar will rise in the ranks regardless.

[-MAKAVELLI-]

a close loss to Margarito does more for Oscar's legacy than does a KO victory over PAC...