168 lbs the best division

[Flawless 2]

WW is the best division than LW than SMW

[Dick-Sucker]

WW is the best division than LW than SMW

Someone call the pest control. Hes back.

[Ryn0]

WW is the best division than LW than SMW

I used to think that but who has it got left? Clottey, Cotto, Williams and Cintron. Judah is moveing down, Mayweather is retired, Mosely might retire or stay at 154, Berto is still very young thne you have the fringe guys like Collazo.

LW and SMW are the two biggest with WW behind.

[Left Hook Tua]

no.

lightweight - pacquiao , marquez , campbell , diaz , guzman , valero......

welterweight - cotto , margarito , williams , mosley , clottey , berto......

junior featherweight - vazquez , marquez , caballero , molitor , lopez......

junior bantamweight - mijares , montiel , darchinyan , arce , donaire......

super middleweight is average.

[Left Hook Tua]

WW is the best division than LW than SMW

i'd switch 147 and 135.

168 is behind 122 and 115 as well.

[Flawless 2]

i'd switch 147 and 135.

168 is behind 122 and 115 as well.

I don't follow anything under 135 usually but if you think so fair enough. NO way is SMW better than 147 and 135.

[IMDAZED]

joe calzaghe (wba super champ)
mikkel kessler (wba)
lucien bute (ibf)
dennis inkin (wbo)
carl froch (fights for vacant wbc)
jean pascal (fights for vacant wbc)
--------------------------------------
jermain taylor (ex middleweight champ)
arthur abraham (forced to move up, ibf middleweight champ)
kelly pavlik (his next fight will be at 170, unlikely he continues as middleweight. wbc,wbo middleweight champ)
--------------------------------------
jeff lacy (ex ibf champ)
anthony mundine (ex wba champ)
sakio bika
edison miranda
librado andrade
allan green
andre dirrell
peter manfredo

Ummm...no. And quite a few of those good names you mentioned aren't even fighting at SMW.

[Bad_Barracuda]

joe calzaghe (wba super champ)
mikkel kessler (wba)
lucien bute (ibf)
dennis inkin (wbo)
carl froch (fights for vacant wbc)
jean pascal (fights for vacant wbc)
--------------------------------------
jermain taylor (ex middleweight champ)
arthur abraham (forced to move up, ibf middleweight champ)
kelly pavlik (his next fight will be at 170, unlikely he continues as middleweight. wbc,wbo middleweight champ)
--------------------------------------
jeff lacy (ex ibf champ)
anthony mundine (ex wba champ)
sakio bika
edison miranda
librado andrade
allan green
andre dirrell
peter manfredo

Lots quantity..very little quality.

168 will always have a sloppy amateur look to it.

[The Hammer]

joe calzaghe (wba super champ)
mikkel kessler (wba)
lucien bute (ibf)
dennis inkin (wbo)
carl froch (fights for vacant wbc)
jean pascal (fights for vacant wbc)
--------------------------------------
jermain taylor (ex middleweight champ)
arthur abraham (forced to move up, ibf middleweight champ)
kelly pavlik (his next fight will be at 170, unlikely he continues as middleweight. wbc,wbo middleweight champ)
--------------------------------------
jeff lacy (ex ibf champ)
anthony mundine (ex wba champ)
sakio bika
edison miranda
librado andrade
allan green
andre dirrell
peter manfredo

I agree - super middleweight has the most talent of any division.

I see a LOT of great potential matchups.

[black.ink]

no.

lightweight - pacquiao , marquez , campbell , diaz , guzman , valero......

welterweight - cotto , margarito , williams , mosley , clottey , berto......

junior featherweight - vazquez , marquez , caballero , molitor , lopez......

junior bantamweight - mijares , montiel , darchinyan , arce , donaire......

super middleweight is average.

Lightweight is the best division followed by Super Fly (115lbs)

SMW is third followed by Welter (past-prime fighters - Marg and Williams should beat everybody else - Cotto, Clottey, Berto are great but there's not enough quality left in the division for it to be considered superior)