I am sorry, but does Beating Andy Kolle signify greatness?

[bsrizpac]

i'm with you on that but i do think williams is a better boxer than margarito

In terms of "skill"? That's not hard.

[Guest]

i know he won but you talk about those fights like if margarito was dominating.
margarito's toughest opponents at 147 are williams,cotto and clottey and i think all 3 of them were winning the fight

Nope not dominating but Margarito beat Cotto and beat Clottey.
And fought Williams tough. He fought 3 guys that are in the top 5 of the division and went 2-1. Not too shabby.

For both guys, I think we can throw out their tune up victories.

[bsrizpac]

Nope not dominating but Margarito beat Cotto and beat Clottey.
And fought Williams tough. He fought 3 guys that are in the top 5 of the division and went 2-1. Not too shabby.

For both guys, I think we can throw out their tune up victories.

Very fair post. Good job.