Who wins a fist fight, BJ Penn or Zab Judah?

[KJB]

LOL @ Anyone picking Zab Judah to win a fight against BJ Penn.
A boxing match? Sure.
But in a full on fight BJ would roll his ass up so fast it wouldnt even be funny. BJ has the kind of natural talent for grappling and fighting overrall that Zab has for boxing, and he isnt a mental midget.

[KJB]

.


Anyone who thinks otherwise needs to go watch Toughman or UFC pathetic display of standup "skills" and leave boxing, K1, or any other real standup stuff to people who understand what they are watching.

OMG dude you sound like such an elitist.
BJ Penn IS a good striker. Elite Pro Boxer level? No. But a lot of MMA fighters have had moderate success at the moderate level in boxing, they arent all **** strikers. The fact is they are well rounded martial artist, so of course they arent striking at the level of an elite pro boxer. That doesnt mean they are different levels of athletes.
One on one, no rules, BJ Penn whoops Zab Judah's ass like he stole something.

[KJB]

Wrong.

Street fights don't go to the ground often. This is not Rio. Rogaine, Dana and the Gracies have fed people that crap for years.

What are the conditions of the street fight. In almost every scenario of any actual street fight between these two, Jab Judah hits him about 7 times before Penn can throw a shot. Penn takes him down. Judah's posse proceed to pull Penn off and beat him to death.

That's a "street fight".

Also the MMA standup is "different" is a pathetic excuse concocted by MMA apologists and *******s like Dana White to excuse the complete inability of most grapplers to even grasp basic concepts like throwing straight punches.

All you pure striking guys love to spew this crap to. Your wrong, street fights go to the ground, ALL THE ****ING TIME. People get involved sometimes, occasionally the fight doesnt hit the ground, but fights hit the ground, and the better grappler provails more often than not in real life.

[HappyBoxingFan]

With boxing rules Zab wins. MMa not so much.

[WLAD OWNS]

Zab would obviously destroy Penn is a fist fight

[shadeyfizzle]

Wrong.

Street fights don't go to the ground often. This is not Rio. Rogaine, Dana and the Gracies have fed people that crap for years.

What are the conditions of the street fight. In almost every scenario of any actual street fight between these two, Jab Judah hits him about 7 times before Penn can throw a shot. Penn takes him down. Judah's posse proceed to pull Penn off and beat him to death.

That's a "street fight".

Also the MMA standup is "different" is a pathetic excuse concocted by MMA apologists and *******s like Dana White to excuse the complete inability of most grapplers to even grasp basic concepts like throwing straight punches.

Either you've never been in a real fight or have always hidden behind 50 homies while instigating one.

Even the most elite boxers get into clinches. With no ref to break it up it would go the ground 99% of the time when 1 guy has no takedown defense.

[Zocalo]

Who ever lands the first flush shot will win...

[Murray]

Jackie Chan KOs Zab (No possies involved)


And does Zab still have a posse since hs is broke?

[Gatti9783]

Zab would take it to him and KO him in 5 seconds or less in a straight fist fight. BJ probably wouldn't get a punch off.

[Zocalo]

I think people love to rag on Zab and it is natural, but I don't doubt that he has devastating one punch knockout power with his fist vs a guy who is his size.