Who is the worst top dog in HW history?

[Welter_Skelter]

I know I didn't list all of the HW's who were considered to be the best HW's cuz I only had 10 option spaces and I basically omitted the choices that I knew for sure weren't gonna have the most votes in the poll. but I gave an 'other' option so you can post if there is another hw you think was the worst hw #1. And this doesn't mean that the fighter had to be ring champ cuz I know Wlad isn't the OFFICIAL ring #1 hw but we all know that he is the top dog in that division so I put him in there.

Of course being the worst champion still means that 99% of the boxing world.. is ****tier that you are.. so it's not like any of these men need to hang their head in shame..They were HW champions after all..

[BlackHat]

What would you think guys if Rocky was in the same era as Ali, foreman, frazier etc. would he be as great?

[Left Hook Tua]

Jess Willard, mostly known for the beating he took against Jack Dempsey.

rumor has it dempsey cheated.

i've seen the video where they show like a piece of metal falling out of his glove.

[The Hammer]

Notice seven of kswizzy99's choice are WHITE champions. Kswizzy99 doesn't like white fighters.

Kswizzy99 is very similar to Flawless - not only does he not like white fighters, he tries to prove they're inferior.

[TheGreatA]

rumor has it dempsey cheated.

i've seen the video where they show like a piece of metal falling out of his glove.

Willard went to his grave believing he had been cheated out of his title.

But I'd say that Willard being 37 years old and having not fought for 3 years was the real reason he lost so badly to Jack Dempsey.

Dempsey did admit to being afraid of Willard because of his size and how he had killed a man in a boxing match. Despite that Dempsey and his managers had made a bet that Dempsey would KO Willard in one.


Leon Spinks


Buster Douglas

[black.ink]

My choices are Fitzsimmons or Willard. To all the people chosing Primo Carnera, you have to remember the man was controlled by the mafia. He had to take a dive in certain fights or his life was on the line. In fights that did not involve the mafia, he battered his competition in brutal fashion. Carnera is one man we will never know just how good he was.

[Davros?]

Out of them it is Primo imo

[Feint]

Primo Carnera.

As soon as the mob lost interest in him he become little more than a punching bag.

[Scott9945]

Primo Carnera.

As soon as the mob lost interest in him he become little more than a punching bag.

That is true. The guy just couldn't fight. He was a terrible heavyweight is a bad era for the division, even compared to now.

[Jim Jeffries]

Funny list. Wlad, Bowe, Marciano and Walcott should definitely not be on there. Marvin Hart, Tommy Burns, Leon Spinks and Buster Douglas, among others, should.