Who has the better resume: Joe Calzaghe vs Floyd Mayweather

[Flawless]

Oscar is 36 coming off a two year lay off with a KO loss.

If anything, hopkins is better than Oscar

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/showthread.php?t=197839

Hopkins was 43 and was way more past his prime than Oscar was against Mayweather. Mayweather was fighting in his 5 weight class above his natural while Joe had only to move one.

[abadger]

Mayweather's resume is better.

[Flawless]

Benn_Foust 54 posts, reason please

[Flawless]

Mayweather's resume is better.

We may disagree but you are the least bias Calzaghe fan

[abadger]

We may disagree but you are the least bias Calzaghe fan

I don't know....I think KrisSilver is less biased than me.

[-----------]

Mayweather easily


But I suppose that this was a ******, sarcastic thread anyway

[Flawless]

Mayweather easily


But I suppose that this was a ******, sarcastic thread anyway

Calzaghe is getting 25 % of the votes. This is a serious post

[boxasmash]

http://www.boxingscene.com/forums/sh...d.php?t=197839

Hopkins was 43 and was way more past his prime than Oscar was against Mayweather. Mayweather was fighting in his 5 weight class above his natural while Joe had only to move one.

Thats rubbish, votes on this forum have no value, I find it hard to believe the majority of people actually believe jones will beat calzaghe for example.

Hopkins was coming in off two high profile wins against top 10 P4p fighters and stayed active (winky and tarver) while Oscar came in off a mayorga win after a 2 year lay off from being KOed. You only got to watch oscar vs forbes to realize oscar is way more shot that Hopkins.

Prime oscar would have stopped forbes in 5.

[Flawless]

Sheika,Mitchell,Brewer,Woodhall

Calzaghe fans do you rate these wins, it's like Mayweather bragging about Baldomir or Gatti

[Dirk Diggler UK]

Flawless, seriously you're the most tedious wet fart on this forum. Anyone who says ANYTHING you disagree with, you gotta make a ****ing poll about it?

Get a life.