If Pacman loses to DLH & Calzaghe beats RJJ;

[TRAVI$]

Will Manny still be P4P #1?
I think so.

[MANGLER]

Pac's status won't change even if he gets KO'd by DLH. He's supposed to lose this fight.

[Silencers]

I think it would be fair to keep him as number 1.

[Flawless]

Calzaghe will be Number one Calzaghe fans eye you watch, they will jump on Manny like a vulcher on a dead body

[abadger]

Calzaghe will be Number one Calzaghe fans eye you watch, they will jump on Manny like a vulcher on a dead body

Really? I think Calzaghe is a better skilled boxer than Pacquiao, but Pacman has been through Barrera, Marquez, Morales and laid some ass whoopings along the way. He's also won titles in five weight classes. Personally I don't think that him losing to a boxer who naturally weighs 25lbs more than he does is enough to elevate Calzaghe to P4P #1 at the moment, and the Jones fight won't change anything because Jones hasn't beaten a live opponent in years.

[Left Hook Tua]

if manny is competitive 50/50 he stays #1.

if manny gets blown out joe will for sure be #1.

if manny beats oscar? no paper/site/network will not have manny #1 , british or not.

[Stickman]

Calzaghe will be Number one Calzaghe fans eye you watch, they will jump on Manny like a vulcher on a dead body

Well...I'm a Zaggs fan, but don't rank him at #1 P4P...Incidentally, I still lean towards JMM at #1 P4P. Loss to Manny or not (and even that is disputed by many, if not most), he's shown to be amazingly complete as a fighter. I can't think of anyone else fighting today that is as skilled technically, and has shown heart and courage at his level.

[Pugilistic™]

Pacquaio should remain as number one being that he should be no where near welterweight and is expected by many to lose.

[Joe2608]

He will still be #1, i think if Calzaghe was facing a credible opponent like Pavlik instead of Jones then Calzaghe would have been number 1, but he decided to take a big money fight instead of a legacy fight.

[TheGreatAli]

Calzaghe is already p4p #1