Prime Mayweather vs Old Oscar = Mayweather SD

[TheGreatAli]

So Prime Oscar vs Prime Mayweather = Oscar UD, agreed?

I actually think if Oscar used his jab in their fight then he could have won anyway.

[Flawless]

What weight class do they fight in?? Mayweather best was 135

[T-97]

What weight class do they fight in?? Mayweather best was 135

^^

Yea. Oscars chin wasn't as good at lower weights either, He was dropped more at those weights than when he moved to 147 and 154.

[Flawless]

I don't think Pernall would be able to knock down Mayweather or Ike would be come Close to Mayweather ar 147.

[j.razor]

So Prime Oscar vs Prime Mayweather = Oscar UD, agreed?

I actually think if Oscar used his jab in their fight then he could have won anyway.

cut it out! oscar never beat a prime fighter anytime....except ike Quartey

[TheGreatAli]

147.

Oscar with more stamina wins the fight.

[Mr. Ryan]

Mayweather was definitely not in his prime. His prime was around the Gatti fight. He was still the best fighter in the world at that point though.

[Flawless]

147.

Oscar with more stamina wins the fight.

You forget when Mayweather fought Oscar he was fighting at 154 Oscar preferred weight class, back down to 147 Mayweather is faster and more powerful. At 140 or 153 Mayweather wins a UD

[Flawless]

I think this Calzaghe fan is making this thread because when asked who would beat a Calzaghe everyone said a prime Hopkins, he is trying to turn the tables on Floyd. Smart bunch of Fans everything they do has a Calzaghe agenda

[tredh]

That fight should have never even been a split decision. PBF cleary won that fight. It should have been scored 8-4 or 9-3. Anything closer I just can't agree with. People in fights stop throwing certain punches either because the **** ain't working(constantly getting countered or blocked) or they are hurt. In De la Hoya case he was missing, getting countered, blocked and he was tired.