Is Joe Calzaghe an ATG great fighter???

[Floyd Sinclair]

Trying to act ****** to deflect you bias one sided views

Hey thats my new friend your talkin too!!!

[Flawless]

Hate is a very powerful word to use for my dislking for Calzaghe. I have numerous reasons first his nuthugger fans and how limey fans and Calzaghe hype Calzaghe and anything linked to him. They say he has done everything when the beat unproven fighters such as Lacy and Kessler and beats past their prime fighters such as Eubank and Hopkins was his hardest fight



Now answer my question

[tredh]

Cotto has beaten Mosley Judah Torres Carlos Quintana

Margarito has beaten Cotto Cintron Clottey

The WW is way better than the SMW

I'll reply because I don't know if your answer is sarcasm. Not the best version of Mosley but it was a solid win nothing more. Not the best version of Judah and unless Judah has a big turn around that win will equate to not being much. Torres and Quintana are not names you want mentioned when discussing you HOF canidacy.

As for Margarito, Cotto is his best win and at that point Cotto hadn't done that much. For Margarito sake he better hope that wasn't the best version of Cotto because that will be seen a very good win but not a win against a great fighter. LMAO at Cintron in the somewhat words of Jay-Z "Cintron only gets half a bar **** that Rican." Clottey is a nice win but controversial because how the fight was playing out before Clottey got hurt.

So neither of them belongs in a HOF conversation if they're careers ended today.

[Floyd Sinclair]

Hate is a very powerful word to use for my dislking for Calzaghe. I have numerous reasons first his nuthugger fans and how limey fans and Calzaghe hype Calzaghe and anything linked to him. They say he has done everything when the beat unproven fighters such as Lacy and Kessler and beats past their prime fighters such as Eubank and Hopkins was his hardest fight



Now answer my question

Thats exactly why i dont like him...i hate most of his **** riding fans

[Don Johnson]

He's not an ATG, yes he deserves to be in the HOF. But thats it he only beat Lacy(see how good he is now), Kessler, and an old old hopkins(he was still good but we saw signs of derterioration in the wright fight). What is this talk about being the greatest SMW of all time? He's not even close to being that, RJJ has hi in the dept but, JC cracks the top 5 with ease. James Toney was a better SMW than JC.

[tredh]

I'm sure both will make it eventually. Cotto will do more and Margarito will be seen as some sort of epic warrior. Give it a few years.

Both have a whole lot of work to do. IMO opinion Margarito's style won't let him last long enough to get it done. Also I feel both will have to eventually move up in weight to accomplish that I don't think either will do well at the higher weights.

[fightnews55]

no!

.......

[Don Johnson]

Thats exactly why i dont like him...i hate most of his **** riding fans

like seriously if it wasn't for me getting on this site, I'd probably like Calzaghe but it's his cum-guzzling fans that make me hate him.

[Flawless]

I'll reply because I don't know if your answer is sarcasm. Not the best version of Mosley but it was a solid win nothing more. Not the best version of Judah and unless Judah has a big turn around that win will equate to not being much. Torres and Quintana are not names you want mentioned when discussing you HOF canidacy.

As for Margarito, Cotto is his best win and at that point Cotto hadn't done that much. For Margarito sake he better hope that wasn't the best version of Cotto because that will be seen a very good win but not a win against a great fighter. LMAO at Cintron in the somewhat words of Jay-Z "Cintron only gets half a bar **** that Rican." Clottey is a nice win but controversial because how the fight was playing out before Clottey got hurt.

So neither of them belongs in a HOF conversation if they're careers ended today.

Mosley = Eubank Both past their primes
Lacy = Torres unproven fighters at the time
Kessler = Judah Both highly talented fighters who have not beaten great opposition yet

[tredh]

Mosley = Eubank Both past their primes
Lacy = Torres unproven fighters at the time
Kessler = Judah Both highly talented fighters who have not beaten great opposition yet

So you agree Cotto and Margarito as of right now don't even belong in a HOF conversation?