Is Joe Calzaghe an ATG great fighter???

[BattlingNelson]

Hofer anyone can make that no big deal but a ATG. Hopkins,RJJ,Mayweather,Winky are all time greats, if Calzaghe is

Why don't you define what ATG means. Otherwise a discussion is hopeless and everybody is correct on the basis of their own criterias.

[abadger]

He is not being sarcastic he actually believes in this

Benn
Watson
Eubank
Kessler

Would all beat a prime RJJ

Ottke too.

And Ernesto Magdeleno.

[T-97]

What bait?

Keep it going. The worms there, Someone is gunna take it!!

[Flawless]

Why don't you define what ATG means. Otherwise a discussion is hopeless and everybody is correct on the basis of their own criterias.

ATG is a fighter who defines the odds who beats other “great” fighters when it mattered, or their boxing ability is beyond imaginable.

[IMDAZED]

Why don't you define what ATG means. Otherwise a discussion is hopeless and everybody is correct on the basis of their own criterias.

Hear hear - I agree.

ATG should be defines as the best of the BEST - the top 50? Perhaps less.

[The Hammer]

You haven't answered the question.

Why do you hate Joe Calzaghe, Flawless?

[Flawless]

Is Tito a ATG
Is Pavlik a ATG if he retires now
Is Hopkins a ATG
Is Toney a ATG
Is Mayweather a ATG
Is Hatton a ATG


The only thing holding Calzaghe up is his 0

[Xyei]

I consider him an ATG and I'm not a fan of JC. The man defended his title 20+ times and while his record could be a little better, that definitely counts for something. A feat that will likely never be accomplished again. He is great at adapting to different styles to win and that is great!

I vote yes!!

[Flawless]

You haven't answered the question.

Why do you hate Joe Calzaghe, Flawless?

I got a question for you, why do you post supremacist white sites which has links to neo **** sites and bigot writers and call other people racist??

[T-97]

Is Tito a ATG

Yes he is IMO. Don't let the last few years of Titos career make you forget what a beast he was at 147.

Is Pavlik a ATG if he retires now

Hell no.

Is Hopkins a ATG

I think so, His 10 year reign at Middleweight and his wins at light heavyweight recently make him worthy

Is Toney a ATG

Mayeb

Is Mayweather a ATG

Yea, 5 weight champ!

Is Hatton a ATG

Helll no!