If Jones Beats Calzaghe Where Does he Go on The p4p List?

[Joe2608]

did'nt Pavlik make it onto Boxingscene p4p their after the Lockett fight

I don't know, but i do know that my P4P list is different to Boxingscene's.

I'm all for Roy coming back but you can't call him P4P number 1 for beating 2 good fighters. If Hopkins wins the Pavlik fight and Roy beats him then we can all use the same excuse that the Americans use against Calzaghe which is Hopkins is old at 43 and a shot fighter. So it will just be 1 good win against Calzaghe. 1 good win doesn't get you on the P4P list.

In the past 4 years he has only won 3 out of 6 fights. The 3 wins were against lackluster competition, all in fairly boring fashion to UD's. Plus, in 2 of the losses he got ktfo. That's not P4P material in my book.

If i'm going to be honest it looks like people are just looking for any old excuse to put Roy Jones back on the P4P list. There are more deserving fighters than a 40 yr old Roy Jones to get on the P4P list.

[Dynamite Kid]

I thought it was after the second Taylor fight .

i might be completely worng but i thought i recalled someone criticising Boxingscene for putting him up there after the Lockett fight

[Dan...]

i might be completely worng but i thought i recalled someone criticising Boxingscene for putting him up there after the Lockett fight

Yeah you are wrong. People were criticising BS for moving him up a place after the Lockett fight but they were mistaken as he only moved up as a result of Floyd's official retirement.

[Dynamite Kid]

Yeah you are wrong. People were criticising BS for moving him up a place after the Lockett fight but they were mistaken as he only moved up as a result of Floyd's official retirement.

okay i thought i heard people complaining about something to do with him and the P4P list after the Lockett fight

[Dan...]

okay i thought i heard people complaining about something to do with him and the P4P list after the Lockett fight

Yeah that would have been it. I think it was mainly that moron UltimateBoxa though, so not a great deal of credibility there.

[Dynamite Kid]

Yeah that would have been it. I think it was mainly that moron UltimateBoxa though, so not a great deal of credibility there.

UltimateBoxa LOL u know that moron is still here some where among us posing as an ALT wish i knew who he was so i could laugh at him some more about Mundine

[Miburo]

What does it matter? He goes into retirement should he win, that's the only place he should go.

[Dan...]

UltimateBoxa LOL u know that moron is still here some where among us posing as an ALT wish i knew who he was so i could laugh at him some more about Mundine

Really? I thought his ALT would be very easy to determine given his Pavlik hatred and Mundine obsession.

[Dynamite Kid]

Really? I thought his ALT would be very easy to determine given his Pavlik hatred and Mundine obsession.

maybe he has left then shame really i liked teasing him

[hishaam15]

would be amazing if he could pull it off though, 3 straight big wins