If Jones Beats Calzaghe Where Does he Go on The p4p List?

[hishaam15]

If they fought and we saw vintage Roy or near enough Prime Roy that night, and he beats Calzaghe

[Joe2608]

He wouldn't even get on myn, beating 1 good fighter doesn't get you on the P4P list.

[Dan...]

It is a pretty good question. Given Roy's achievements and resume I think a win over Calzaghe would put him back in the top 10, only just though.

[Zocalo]

He would be in the top 10... but there would be significant debate where he would be. I mean Hopkins is still considered a top 10 p4p fighter in most people eyes and if Roy can beat Joe, it is hard to say he isn't worthy of being in the top 10 p4p list.

[hishaam15]

if he beat him conviningly i would put him back in the top 5
if it was close i would put him in top 10

if he beat hops/pav winner after that he wouldd be number 1

[Joe2608]

if he beat him conviningly i would put him back in the top 5
if it was close i would put him in top 10

if he beat hops/pav winner after that he wouldd be number 1

lmao, are you serious?

[Dynamite Kid]

He wouldn't even get on myn, beating 1 good fighter doesn't get you on the P4P list.

did'nt Pavlik make it onto Boxingscene p4p their after the Lockett fight

[RodBarker]

did'nt Pavlik make it onto Boxingscene p4p their after the Lockett fight

I thought it was after the second Taylor fight .

[hishaam15]

lmao, are you serious?

lol yeh why not? i said if we saw a VINTAGE roy then i would. and joe is around number 2. knocking him out will put him in the top 10. then beating pav ill put him in the top 3. avenge the loss to Tarver and you got p4p number 1 back

[RichCCFC]

Depends how he looks, 5th max though.