Why did Mayweather's level of competition deteriorate after Castillo?

Collapse
Collapse
  • Time
  • Show
Clear All
new posts
  • BASILISK
    Banned
    • Aug 2008
    • 130
    • 25
    • 8
    • 212

    #1

    Why did Mayweather's level of competition deteriorate after Castillo?

    Ricky Hatton=good
    Oscar De La Hoya=past prime good
    Carlos Manuel Baldomir=lucky fringe contender
    Zab Judah=fringe
    Sharmba Mitchell=fringe
    Arturo Gatti=fringe
    Henry Bruseles=bum
    DeMarcus Corley= a little better than bum
    Phillip N'dou=bum
    Victoriano Sosa=bum

    He fought only 2 good fighters after the castillo fight. Why did he take such rubbish fights?
  • C'MONMANG'
    Banned
    Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
    • Oct 2007
    • 7002
    • 172
    • 21
    • 7,389

    #2
    Originally posted by BASILISK
    Ricky Hatton=good
    Oscar De La Hoya=past prime good
    Carlos Manuel Baldomir=lucky fringe contender
    Zab Judah=fringe
    Sharmba Mitchell=fringe
    Arturo Gatti=fringe
    Henry Bruseles=bum
    DeMarcus Corley= a little better than bum
    Phillip N'dou=bum
    Victoriano Sosa=bum

    He fought only 2 good fighters after the castillo fight. Why did he take such rubbish fights?
    he wanted to protect his 0 mainly...

    Comment

    • BASILISK
      Banned
      • Aug 2008
      • 130
      • 25
      • 8
      • 212

      #3
      Originally posted by C'MONMANG'
      he wanted to protect his 0 mainly...
      He rather do that then face the best? I thought mayweather was a warrior

      Comment

      • larryx
        Banned
        Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
        • May 2008
        • 13892
        • 225
        • 108
        • 15,442

        #4
        yea he won 3 more titles!!!terrible opposition huh!!!zab judah fringe contender???he was the linear champ 1 fight before,baldo was the champ,cant knock him for gotti he had a belt,and mostly the rest were tune up fights//mosley and cotto didnt wanna fight him so whats your point?

        Comment

        • El Dominicano
          Banned
          • Aug 2007
          • 10074
          • 226
          • 49
          • 10,758

          #5
          Originally posted by BASILISK
          Ricky Hatton=good
          Oscar De La Hoya=past prime good
          Carlos Manuel Baldomir=lucky fringe contender
          Zab Judah=fringe
          Sharmba Mitchell=fringe
          Arturo Gatti=fringe
          Henry Bruseles=bum
          DeMarcus Corley= a little better than bum
          Phillip N'dou=bum
          Victoriano Sosa=bum

          He fought only 2 good fighters after the castillo fight. Why did he take such rubbish fights?
          Sosa is not a bum he was so damn talented and a complete fighter, he just didn't have power. Btw, not saying tha becuz he is Dominican. Hatton was a good win but we'd never know how good Hatton is becuz Hatton didn't fight Witter Toress Cotto @ 140 and many more. I'd say Hatton is still unproven. Gatti has always been a punching bag. Zab on the other hand, that was a fight EVERYONE wanted to see. If you were a boxing fan at the time you'd know that was a fight people wanted to see becuz Zab had faster hand speed and more power then Mayweather and could box beutifully, Watch the Zab vs Spinks and Corely.
          Last edited by El Dominicano; 08-12-2008, 07:36 PM.

          Comment

          • El Dominicano
            Banned
            • Aug 2007
            • 10074
            • 226
            • 49
            • 10,758

            #6
            Originally posted by larryx
            yea he won 3 more titles!!!terrible opposition huh!!!zab judah fringe contender???he was the linear champ 1 fight before,baldo was the champ,cant knock him for gotti he had a belt,and mostly the rest were tune up fights//mosley and cotto didnt wanna fight him so whats your point?
            Mosely and Winky didn't wana fight Mayweather. Cotto didn't wana fight Mayweather @ 140. They diss his resume but don't look at the fighters Mayweather called out.

            Comment

            • C'MONMANG'
              Banned
              Super Champion - 5,000-10,000 posts
              • Oct 2007
              • 7002
              • 172
              • 21
              • 7,389

              #7
              Originally posted by El Dominicano
              Sosa is not a bum he was so damn talented and a complete fighter, he just didn't have power. Btw, not saying tha becuz he is Dominican. Hatton was a good win but we'd never know how good Hatton is becuz Hatton didn't fight Witter Toress Cotto @ 140 and many more. I'd say Hatton is still unproven. Gatti has always been a punching bag. Zab on the other hand, that was a fight EVERYONE wanted to see. If you were a boxing fan at the time you'd know that was a fight people wanted to see becuz Paul had faster hand speed more power and could box beutifully, Watch the Zab vs Spinks and Corely.
              he won a split D against Corely....HE looked average

              Comment

              • BASILISK
                Banned
                • Aug 2008
                • 130
                • 25
                • 8
                • 212

                #8
                Originally posted by El Dominicano
                Sosa is not a bum he was so damn talented and a complete fighter, he just didn't have power. Btw, not saying tha becuz he is Dominican. Hatton was a good win but we'd never know how good Hatton is becuz Hatton didn't fight Witter Toress Cotto @ 140 and many more. I'd say Hatton is still unproven. Gatti has always been a punching bag. Zab on the other hand, that was a fight EVERYONE wanted to see. If you were a boxing fan at the time you'd know that was a fight people wanted to see becuz Zab had faster hand speed more power and could box beutifully, Watch the Zab vs Spinks and Corely.

                wait.. Can a fighter be a complete fighter if they dont have power? please help me out here my mind is spinning

                Comment

                • El Dominicano
                  Banned
                  • Aug 2007
                  • 10074
                  • 226
                  • 49
                  • 10,758

                  #9
                  Originally posted by BASILISK
                  wait.. Can a fighter be a complete fighter if they dont have power? please help me out here my mind is spinning
                  I'd still say so. Should have said he didn't have enough power. Joan Guzman is complete, wouldn't you say?

                  Comment

                  • Fox McCloud
                    Mission Complete!
                    Unified Champion - 10,00-20,000 posts
                    • Apr 2007
                    • 18176
                    • 789
                    • 1,151
                    • 26,037

                    #10
                    Originally posted by C'MONMANG'
                    he won a split D against Corely....HE looked average
                    That bout was absolutely asstastic. Neither put their best effort forward it didn't look like.

                    Other than that absolutely devastating crushing left hand that Judah dropped Corley with, that bout was, like you said, extremely average.

                    Comment

                    Working...
                    TOP