Your top10 all time welterweights

[Slotff]

1. Golden Johnson
2. Oscar de la Hoya
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Harold Ledderman
5. There is no #5
6. See number 8
7. See number 6
8. See number 7
9. Paulie Malignaggi
10. Crazy Kim.

[Left Hook Tua]

1. Golden Johnson
2. Oscar de la Hoya
3. Manny Pacquiao
4. Harold Ledderman
5. There is no #5
6. See number 8
7. See number 6
8. See number 7
9. Paulie Malignaggi
10. Crazy Kim.

they should have a welterweight tournament.

oscar vs. kim
harold vs. paulie
manny vs. bobby

the survivor gets to take on golden

[C'MONMANG']

Would you get hard if he replaced Margarito with Williams?

lol.....................

[LEFTYGUNZZ]

So what your saying is, as long as he doesnt face his biggest threat, and just adds a bunch of W's, his legacy will be even better?

I don't see paul Williams as a true Welter Weight to me he is a FREAK and I have stated it before. Margarito fought him already and lost I said it are you happy. i saw the fight on HBO and truely I wasn't very entertained by Willams throw his slapping punches watching hi long lanky arms and sickly looking body move around the ring. If they rematch they do if not I could care less.....I rather see a more entertaining fight at 147 like Marg fight Mosely or rematch Cotto then see him fight Williams. It seems like every time you mention Margarito name you get these Paul Williams replies.

to clear up my statment about Margarito I say he will probaly stay at WW i see Williams moving up to Middle weight and even Light HEavy very soon. no one wants to fight THE FREAK at WW because it is like a average size man 5'8 - 5'10 fighting a midget that weighs 147 pounds....it is not very entertaining and makes for a boring fight......Lefty

[C'MONMANG']

So what your saying is, as long as he doesnt face his biggest threat, and just adds a bunch of W's, his legacy will be even better?

.................................

[THE REED]

I threw him up for sake of it. I think he has legendary Stamina and throws punches after punches after punches and will give any one of the guys on the list trouble....I listed for that reason and if he fights a few more good fighters not named Paul Williams he will add to his W total and maybe KO title. the guy haS NEVER been stopped either.....Lefty

I just dont get this...

he ll be ranked higher as long as he doesnt fight his biggest threat? and gets more wins?

[Jim Jeffries]

I don't see paul Williams as a true Welter Weight to me he is a FREAK and I have stated it before. Margarito fought him already and lost I said it are you happy. i saw the fight on HBO and truely I wasn't very entertained by Willams throw his slapping punches watching hi long lanky arms and sickly looking body move around the ring. If they rematch they do if not I could care less.....I rather see a more entertaining fight at 147 like Marg fight Mosely or rematch Cotto then see him fight Williams. It seems like every time you mention Margarito name you get these Paul Williams replies.

to clear up my statment about Margarito I say he will probaly stay at WW i see Williams moving up to Middle weight and even Light HEavy very soon. no one wants to fight THE FREAK at WW because it is like a average size man 5'8 - 5'10 fighting a midget that weighs 147 pounds....it is not very entertaining and makes for a boring fight......Lefty

After losing to one of Cotto's victims since the Margarito fight, Williams should have to fight Cotto to earn a rematch with Tony. Or someone like Clottey at least. Both of whom I think would beat Williams.

[THE REED]

I don't see paul Williams as a true Welter Weight to me he is a FREAK and I have stated it before. Margarito fought him already and lost I said it are you happy. i saw the fight on HBO and truely I wasn't very entertained by Willams throw his slapping punches watching hi long lanky arms and sickly looking body move around the ring. If they rematch they do if not I could care less.....I rather see a more entertaining fight at 147 like Marg fight Mosely or rematch Cotto then see him fight Williams. It seems like every time you mention Margarito name you get these Paul Williams replies.

to clear up my statment about Margarito I say he will probaly stay at WW i see Williams moving up to Middle weight and even Light HEavy very soon. no one wants to fight THE FREAK at WW because it is like a average size man 5'8 - 5'10 fighting a midget that weighs 147 pounds....it is not very entertaining and makes for a boring fight......Lefty

Making weight is COMPLETLY RELATIVE...

I can't wrap my head around why people think its unfair that one guy is taller, so he should be in a higher weight class...?????


If a guy is 5 7 like cotto, and is at his strongest weight at 147...

and another guy has to weight drain down to 147 but hes bigger... its the same to me... because the 2nd guy is WEIGHT DRAINED, so even though hes taller (which shouldnt matter) hes not at his best or his strongest because hes weight drained... so whats the difference?

thats why they have weight limitations and not height limitations... if you can make the weight, then its fair... everyone is built differently...

paul isnt going to have the leg strength that margarito has... everyone is built differently...

[Jim Jeffries]

Making weight is COMPLETLY RELATIVE...

I can't wrap my head around why people think its unfair that one guy is taller, so he should be in a higher weight class...?????


If a guy is 5 7 like cotto, and is at his strongest weight at 147...

and another guy has to weight drain down to 147 but hes bigger... its the same to me... because the 2nd guy is WEIGHT DRAINED, so even though hes taller (which shouldnt matter) hes not at his best or his strongest because hes weight drained... so whats the difference?

thats why they have weight limitations and not height limitations... if you can make the weight, then its fair... everyone is built differently...

paul isnt going to have the leg strength that margarito has... everyone is built differently...

We should go back to same day weigh-ins, problem solved. Then you wouldn't have freaks that have a full day or more to rehydrate 15 - 20 lbs.

[THE REED]

We should go back to same day weigh-ins, problem solved. Then you wouldn't have freaks that have a full day or more to rehydrate 15 - 20 lbs.

i wouldnt have a problem with that....


i think paul williams has an incredibly slender body, hes tall but VERY slender... i thin if weight was a HUGE deal to him, he wouldnt be able to perform the way he has...